Gilman E A, Knox E G
Department of Public Health and Epidemiology, The Medical School, University of Birmingham, Edgbaston.
J Epidemiol Community Health. 1995 Apr;49(2):158-63. doi: 10.1136/jech.49.2.158.
To examine a national data set of all childhood cancers for evidence of space-time interactions within three distinct sets of dates and places (at birth, at diagnosis, and at death), to show whether the patterns found for these events represent separate phenomena or statistically interdependent processes, and to see whether the childhood leukaemias and the childhood solid cancers have separate distinctive patterns in these respects.
This was a space-time cluster analysis. The large number of cases enabled division of the data into two sets, one for hypothesis generation and the other for hypothesis testing.
England, Scotland, and Wales.
A national collection of 22,360 children aged 0-15 years with fatal cancers and leukaemias in the period 1953 to 1980.
There was significant clustering among the leukaemias and lymphomas on date and place of birth (particularly among cases born within 1 km and up to 5 months apart), and on date and place of diagnosis (particularly among cases diagnosed from 3 to 5 km apart and up to 9 months apart). There was no clustering among the solid cancers. These findings were confirmed in two separate analyses of two separate sets of data.
The birth clustering was significant among pairs diagnosed at differing ages, and diagnosis clustering was significant among pairs born at different times, and it was concluded that the two types of clustering must be regarded as separate and statistically independent phenomena. Both the birth and the diagnosis clusters comprised many independent pairs of cases, with no large multiple case clusters. This suggests the involvement of multiple time-space localised exposures to hazards with short and constant latent intervals; probably an infectious agent or an environmental toxin. Given the separate nature of the two types of clustering, exposure to more than one hazard may be involved.
检查所有儿童癌症的全国数据集,以寻找在三个不同的日期和地点集合(出生时、诊断时和死亡时)内时空交互作用的证据,确定这些事件所发现的模式是代表独立现象还是统计上相互依存的过程,并查看儿童白血病和儿童实体癌在这些方面是否有各自独特的模式。
这是一项时空聚类分析。大量病例使得数据能够分为两组,一组用于生成假设,另一组用于检验假设。
英格兰、苏格兰和威尔士。
1953年至1980年期间全国收集的22360名0至15岁患有致命癌症和白血病的儿童。
白血病和淋巴瘤在出生日期和地点(特别是出生在相距1公里以内且间隔最多5个月的病例之间)以及诊断日期和地点(特别是诊断时相距3至5公里且间隔最多9个月的病例之间)存在显著聚类。实体癌之间没有聚类。这些发现在对两组不同数据的两次单独分析中得到了证实。
出生聚类在不同年龄诊断的病例对中具有显著性,诊断聚类在不同时间出生的病例对中具有显著性,因此得出结论,这两种聚类类型必须被视为独立且统计上相互独立的现象。出生和诊断聚类都包含许多独立的病例对,没有大的多病例聚类。这表明涉及多次时空局部暴露于具有短且恒定潜伏期的危害因素;可能是一种传染因子或环境毒素。鉴于这两种聚类类型的独立性,可能涉及暴露于不止一种危害因素。