Rahaman M M, Majid M A, Islam M R
Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 1976 Oct;10(4):610-2. doi: 10.1128/AAC.10.4.610.
In 51 actively purging cholera patients the efficacy of doxycycline, a long-acting tetracycline, was compared with a placebo and tetracycline hydrochloride. Seventeen patients who were given doxycycline at the recommended dose of 2 mg/kg at the beginning of the study, at 12 h, and at the repeated dose once daily purged a mean volume of 5.1 liters of stool and received an average of 5.7 liters of intravenous fluid. Nineteen patients receiving the placebo purged 10.1 liters of stool and received 9.7 liters of fluid. Fifteen patients given tetracycline hydrochloride at 6-h intervals passed 4.8 liters of stool and received 5.5 liters of fluid. The durations of diarrhea calculated in 8-h periods were 3.5, 8.0, and 4.1 h in the respective groups receiving doxycycline, placebo, and tetracycline. The differences between the doxycycline and placebo treatments and the tetracycline and placebo treatments were statistically significant. Those receiving doxycycline became vibrio-free in about 3 days as compared with 2 days for those receiving tetracycline; the group given the placebo were vibrio positive for the duration of their hospitalization. The results show that in the treatment of cholera the administration of doxycycline once daily has effects equal to those when tetracycline is administered at 6-h intervals. This is a distinct advantage because it decreases the demand on nursing personnel in epidemics. Also, doxycycline may be safely administered in cases of suspected renal failure from prolonged shock in cholera.
在51例正在积极排菌的霍乱患者中,对长效四环素强力霉素的疗效与安慰剂及盐酸四环素进行了比较。17例患者在研究开始时、12小时时以及之后每天重复给药一次,按推荐剂量2mg/kg给予强力霉素,这些患者平均排粪便量为5.1升,平均接受静脉补液5.7升。19例接受安慰剂的患者排粪便量为10.1升,接受补液9.7升。15例每隔6小时给予盐酸四环素的患者排粪便量为4.8升,接受补液5.5升。分别接受强力霉素、安慰剂和四环素治疗的组,以8小时时间段计算的腹泻持续时间分别为3.5小时、8.0小时和4.1小时。强力霉素与安慰剂治疗组之间以及四环素与安慰剂治疗组之间的差异具有统计学意义。接受强力霉素治疗的患者大约3天内霍乱弧菌转阴,而接受四环素治疗的患者为2天;接受安慰剂的组在住院期间霍乱弧菌一直呈阳性。结果表明,在霍乱治疗中,每天给药一次强力霉素的效果与每隔6小时给药一次四环素的效果相当。这是一个明显的优势,因为在疫情期间它减少了对护理人员的需求。此外,在因霍乱长时间休克而疑似肾衰竭的病例中,强力霉素也可安全使用。