Berry G
Ann Occup Hyg. 1994 Aug;38(4):539-46, 413. doi: 10.1093/annhyg/38.4.539.
Three studies provide data on this topic. The largest was at the Ferodo factory in the U.K. There was no evidence of an overall excess in mortality from all causes, and in particular no increase in mortality due to lung cancer. Also, there was no evidence of any dose-response effect for lung cancer. There were 13 mesotheliomas but for 10 of these there had been exposure to crocidolite whilst working on a special contract that only a small minority of the workforce were involved in. Another one had worked in an asbestos-cement factory for 20 years. This left two mesotheliomas, one unconfirmed, for which the only known exposure was to chrysotile asbestos. The second study was of a plant in Connecticut. There was a significant increase in mortality due to respiratory cancer, but this excess was greatest in those with less than 1 year's exposure and was unrelated to cumulative exposure. No mesotheliomas occurred. The third study was of two factories in Ontario manufacturing automotive components. There was a non-significant increase in lung cancer mortality but the majority of these had not worked in the departments where asbestos was used. There were two unconfirmed mesotheliomas, one of whom had worked with friction materials. In conclusion, the three studies show that, if there are any effects on mortality due to working in the manufacture of friction materials, these effects must be small.
三项研究提供了关于该主题的数据。规模最大的一项研究是在英国的费罗多工厂进行的。没有证据表明所有原因导致的总体死亡率过高,尤其是肺癌死亡率没有增加。此外,也没有证据表明肺癌存在任何剂量反应效应。有13例间皮瘤病例,但其中10例是在从事一份只有少数劳动力参与的特殊合同时接触过青石棉。另一例曾在一家石棉水泥厂工作了20年。这样就剩下两例间皮瘤病例,其中一例未经证实,其唯一已知的接触物是温石棉。第二项研究是关于康涅狄格州的一家工厂。呼吸道癌症导致的死亡率显著增加,但这种过高的死亡率在接触时间不到1年的人群中最为明显,且与累积接触无关。没有发生间皮瘤病例。第三项研究是关于安大略省两家制造汽车零部件的工厂。肺癌死亡率有不显著的增加,但其中大多数人并非在使用石棉的部门工作。有两例未经证实的间皮瘤病例,其中一例曾从事摩擦材料工作。总之,这三项研究表明,如果在摩擦材料制造行业工作对死亡率有任何影响,这些影响肯定很小。