O'Keeffe S T, Tormey W P, Glasgow R, Lavan J N
Department of Geriatric Medicine, Beaumont Hospital, Dublin, Republic of Ireland.
Gerontology. 1994;40(1):18-24. doi: 10.1159/000213570.
Necropsy studies suggest that thiamine deficiency is underdiagnosed in life, in part because the classical clinical presentations are uncommon. Anecdotal reports suggest that thiamine deficiency may contribute to the development of delirium, heart failure and peripheral neuropathy in elderly patients, but little systematic research has been reported. We examined thiamine levels in 36 consecutive non-demented, community-dwelling patients admitted to an acute geriatric unit. Marginal thiamine deficiency [thiamine pyrophosphate effect (TPPE) 15-24%] was present in 11 (31%) and definite thiamine deficiency (TPPE > 25%) in 6 (17%) patients. Delirium occurred in 6/19 (32%) patients with normal thiamine status and 13/17 (76%) thiamine-deficient patients (p < 0.025, chi 2 test). One or more other possible causes for delirium were present in all cases. One patient had ocular signs and a dramatic clinical response to vitamin B complex therapy. Absent ankle jerks were noted in 2/19 (10%) patients with normal thiamine status and 7/17 (41%) patients with thiamine deficiency (p = 0.06). There was no difference in anthropometric indices or in the prevalence of other nutrient deficiencies between the two groups. Thiamine deficiency is common in elderly patients admitted to hospital and may contribute to the development of delirium.
尸检研究表明,硫胺素缺乏症在生前常被漏诊,部分原因是其典型临床表现并不常见。轶事报道表明,硫胺素缺乏可能导致老年患者出现谵妄、心力衰竭和周围神经病变,但鲜有系统性研究报道。我们对36例连续入住急性老年病房的非痴呆社区居民患者的硫胺素水平进行了检测。11例(31%)患者存在边缘性硫胺素缺乏[硫胺素焦磷酸效应(TPPE)为15%-24%],6例(17%)患者存在明确的硫胺素缺乏(TPPE>25%)。硫胺素水平正常的患者中有6/19(32%)发生谵妄,硫胺素缺乏的患者中有13/17(76%)发生谵妄(p<0.025,卡方检验)。所有病例均存在一种或多种其他可能导致谵妄的原因。1例患者有眼部体征,对复合维生素B治疗有显著临床反应。硫胺素水平正常的患者中有2/19(10%)未引出踝反射,硫胺素缺乏的患者中有7/17(41%)未引出踝反射(p=0.06)。两组间人体测量指标或其他营养素缺乏的患病率无差异。硫胺素缺乏在住院老年患者中很常见,可能导致谵妄的发生。