Victor M
Department of Medicine (Neurology), Dartmouth Medical School, Hanover, New Hampshire.
Can J Neurol Sci. 1994 May;21(2):88-99. doi: 10.1017/s031716710004899x.
At least four distinct cerebral diseases--Wernicke-Korsakoff, Marchiafava-Bignami, pellagrous encephalopathy, and acquired hepatocerebral degeneration--have a close association with chronic alcoholism. Each is characterized by a distinctive pathologic change and a reasonably well-established pathogenesis; in each the role of alcohol in the causation is secondary. The question posed in this review is whether there is, in addition to the established types of dementia associated with alcoholism, a persistent dementia attributable to the direct toxic effects of alcohol on the brain--i.e., a primary alcoholic dementia. The clinical, psychologic, radiologic, and pathologic evidence bearing on this question is critically reviewed. None of the evidence permits the clear delineation of such an entity. The most serious flaw in the argument for a primary alcoholic dementia is that it lacks a distinctive, well-defined pathology, and it must remain ambiguous until such time as its morphologic basis is established.
至少有四种不同的脑部疾病——韦尼克-科尔萨科夫综合征、马基亚法瓦-比尼亚米病、糙皮病性脑病和获得性肝脑变性——与慢性酒精中毒密切相关。每种疾病都有独特的病理变化和相当明确的发病机制;在每种疾病中,酒精在病因中的作用都是次要的。本综述提出的问题是,除了已确定的与酒精中毒相关的痴呆类型外,是否存在一种由酒精对大脑的直接毒性作用导致的持续性痴呆——即原发性酒精性痴呆。本文对与此问题相关的临床、心理、放射学和病理学证据进行了批判性综述。没有任何证据能够清晰地界定这样一种实体。支持原发性酒精性痴呆的观点最严重的缺陷在于它缺乏独特、明确的病理学特征,在其形态学基础确立之前,它必然仍不明确。