Cook W L, Goldstein M J
University of Texas, Austin.
Child Dev. 1993 Oct;64(5):1377-88. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-8624.1993.tb02958.x.
Many scholars are skeptical of family member reports on their interpersonal relationships. Familial reports are assumed to be biased by social desirability as well as other factors. In this study, a latent variables modeling approach was employed to evaluate rater reliability and bias in mother, father, and child ratings of parent-child negativity. Results based on 78 clinical families demonstrate that family member ratings contain a significant "true score" component that correlates with observer ratings of parental behavior. The presence of systematic rater effects is also demonstrated. The latent variables approach, which provides statistical control for rater effects, is recommended for the analysis of this type of data.
许多学者对家庭成员关于其人际关系的报告持怀疑态度。家庭报告被认为会受到社会期望以及其他因素的影响而产生偏差。在本研究中,采用了一种潜在变量建模方法来评估母亲、父亲和孩子对亲子负性情绪评分中的评分者信度和偏差。基于78个临床家庭的结果表明,家庭成员的评分包含一个与父母行为的观察者评分相关的显著“真分数”成分。同时也证明了存在系统性的评分者效应。建议采用能对评分者效应进行统计控制的潜在变量方法来分析这类数据。