Heywang-Köbrunner S H, Schlegel A, Beck R, Wendt T, Kellner W, Lommatzsch B, Untch M, Nathrath W B
Department of Radiology, University of Leipzig, Germany.
J Comput Assist Tomogr. 1993 Nov-Dec;17(6):891-900. doi: 10.1097/00004728-199311000-00009.
Posttherapeutic changes in the breast after tumorectomy (TE) and radiation therapy (RT) may mimic or obscure recurrent or new malignancies and thus interfere with conventional diagnostic studies. We investigated the enhancement of tissue during variable time intervals after therapy with contrast-enhanced MRI in 62 patients.
We report the results of 77 studies in 62 patients undergoing TE and RT. We include only those studies with at least 24 months of clinical and mammographic follow-up (n = 60) or histopathologic results (n = 17).
Up to 9 months after therapy, differentiation between posttherapeutic changes and recurrence was frequently impossible because of the strong enhancement. Ten to 18 months after therapy, this posttherapeutic enhancement subsided slowly with some interindividual variations. After 18 months posttherapy, no significant enhancement was encountered in 30 of 32 cases. Diffuse or focal enhancement was present in all recurrent tumors and all recurrences were correctly diagnosed. Furthermore, 4 of 11 recurrences and 10 of 18 single recurrent foci were detected by MR alone, based on focal enhancement.
Accordingly, contrast-enhanced MR is not recommended during the first 9 months after therapy. Nine to 18 months after therapy, it may be helpful in those two-thirds of cases where the scar does not enhance. If enhancement takes place (one-third of cases), it may represent either scar or tumor, and in such circumstances, enhanced MR is of no value. After 18 months, enhanced MRI has proven a valuable additional tool. By correctly detecting or excluding recurrent tumor, it can significantly improve diagnostic accuracy.
肿瘤切除术后(TE)及放疗(RT)后乳房的治疗后改变可能会模仿或掩盖复发性或新发恶性肿瘤,从而干扰传统诊断研究。我们利用对比增强磁共振成像(MRI)对62例患者治疗后不同时间间隔的组织强化情况进行了研究。
我们报告了62例接受TE和RT患者的77项研究结果。我们仅纳入那些具有至少24个月临床和乳腺X线摄影随访(n = 60)或组织病理学结果(n = 17)的研究。
治疗后长达9个月,由于强化明显,治疗后改变与复发之间常常难以区分。治疗后10至18个月,这种治疗后强化逐渐缓慢消退,个体间存在一些差异。治疗后18个月后,32例中有30例未出现明显强化。所有复发性肿瘤均出现弥漫性或局灶性强化,且所有复发均被正确诊断。此外,基于局灶性强化,11例复发中有4例以及18个单发复发病灶中有10例仅通过磁共振成像检测到。
因此,不建议在治疗后的前9个月进行对比增强磁共振成像检查。治疗后9至18个月,对于三分之二瘢痕无强化的病例可能有帮助。如果出现强化(三分之一的病例),可能代表瘢痕或肿瘤,在这种情况下,增强磁共振成像无价值。18个月后,增强磁共振成像已被证明是一种有价值的辅助工具。通过正确检测或排除复发性肿瘤,它可以显著提高诊断准确性。