Siboni A H, Holmegaard S N
Medicinsk afdeling, Sundby Hospital, København.
Ugeskr Laeger. 1993 Nov 22;155(47):3840-4.
During 208 days 2836 patients were admitted to Sundby Hospital, medical ward. A total of 734 antibiotic cures were initiated. About 632 (22-23%) of the patients had antibiotic treatment. Penicillin, ampicillin and sulfamethizole were the most frequently used antibiotics. The use of erythromycin was 42-50% and 64-78% of that of penicillin and ampicillin respectively. Antibiotic treatment was changed in 99 cures in 73 patients. Fifty-seven of ninety-nine (43-71%) shifts were based on culture or serology and 42/99 (29-57%) shifts were based on clinical evaluation including microscopy and urinary stix. In 26 of the latter 42 cases positive culture or serology was obtained after the antibiotic was changed. Thirteen of the 26 shifts improved treatment, six were unlucky and seven indifferent, thus giving a net advantage of 13-6 = 7 of 26 shifts. This net advantage was due to shifts from penicillin. In ten cases the antibiotic was shifted to erythromycin due to suspected atypical pneumonia, but only one case was verified. In ten antibiotic shifts in pneumonia patients the etiologic agents were not identified. In 4/99 shifts in 4/73 patients relevant specimens were not obtained. The antibiotic most often changed compared with its total use was ampicillin (32/152 congruent to 1/5 of initiated cures) and shifts from ampicillin were more often (21/32) based on culture than shifts from penicillin (16/36) (p < 0.1). Initial supplementation of ampicillin with aminoglycosides was retrospectively relevant in 13/28 cases. Cephalosporines (p < 0.001) and dicloxacillin (p < 0.02) were significantly more often used as second drug, whereas penicillin was most often used as first drug (p < 0.001).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
在208天里,2836名患者住进了桑德比医院内科病房。共启动了734例抗生素治疗。约632名(22% - 23%)患者接受了抗生素治疗。青霉素、氨苄西林和磺胺甲噻二唑是最常用的抗生素。红霉素的使用量分别为青霉素和氨苄西林的42% - 50%以及64% - 78%。73名患者的99例治疗中更换了抗生素。99次换药中有57次(43% - 71%)是基于培养或血清学检查,42/99次(29% - 57%)是基于包括显微镜检查和尿液试纸检查在内的临床评估。在后42例中,26例在更换抗生素后获得了阳性培养结果或血清学检查结果。这26次换药中有13次改善了治疗效果,6次运气不佳,7次无明显效果,因此26次换药的净优势为13 - 6 = 7次。这种净优势归因于从青霉素的换药。10例因疑似非典型肺炎将抗生素换为红霉素,但仅1例得到证实。10例肺炎患者换药时未明确病原体。73名患者中有4名的99次换药中未获取相关标本。与总使用量相比,最常更换的抗生素是氨苄西林(32/152约等于起始治疗量的1/5),且从氨苄西林换药基于培养的情况比从青霉素换药(16/36)更常见(p < 0.1)。回顾性分析显示,28例中有13例初始时氨苄西林与氨基糖苷类联用是合理的。头孢菌素(p < 0.001)和双氯西林(p < 0.02)作为第二种药物使用的频率显著更高,而青霉素最常作为第一种药物使用(p < 0.001)。(摘要截选至250字)