Prakash J V, Khare P M, Haridas V
Department of Microbiology, Grant Medical College, Byculla, Bombay.
Indian J Pathol Microbiol. 1993 Apr;36(2):138-42.
A commercially available particle agglutination test (PA) was evaluated for its specificity and sensitivity as compared to ELISA currently used in our laboratory to detect HIV-I antibodies. A total of 463 sera from blood donors and clinical referrals were screened by PA, 45 were found to be positive (9.7%). Out of 463, 258 sera were simultaneously screened by ELISA; 28 were found to be positive (10.8%). Twelve samples showing positive results by both ELISA & PA were tested by Western blot and were confirmed to be positive. We found sensitivity of PA as compared to ELISA as 100% and specificity to be 88.44%. Readings of PA taken at 2 hrs should be reconfirmed at 24 hrs as it eliminates a number of false positives. Overall, we feel PA is fairly comparable with ELISA. It can be used in the set up where equipment and trained personnel for ELISA are not available for primary screening purposes.
我们评估了一种市售颗粒凝集试验(PA)相对于目前我们实验室用于检测HIV-1抗体的ELISA的特异性和敏感性。共有463份来自献血者和临床转诊患者的血清通过PA进行筛查,发现45份呈阳性(9.7%)。在463份血清中,258份同时通过ELISA进行筛查;发现28份呈阳性(10.8%)。12份ELISA和PA均呈阳性的样本通过免疫印迹法进行检测,并被确认为阳性。我们发现PA相对于ELISA的敏感性为100%,特异性为88.44%。PA在2小时读取的结果应在24小时重新确认,因为这可以消除一些假阳性。总体而言,我们认为PA与ELISA相当。在没有用于ELISA的设备和经过培训的人员进行初步筛查的情况下,可以使用PA。