Boyatzis C J, Watson M W
Brandeis University.
Child Dev. 1993 Jun;64(3):729-35.
To investigate the symbolic quality of preschoolers' gestural representations in the absence of real objects, 48 children (16 3-, 4-, and 5-year-olds) performed 2 tasks. In the first task, they were asked to pretend to use 8 common objects (e.g., "pretend to brush your teeth with a toothbrush"). There was an age-related progression in the symbolic quality of gestural representations. 3- and 4-year-olds used mostly body part gestures (e.g., using an extended finger as the toothbrush), whereas 5-year-olds used imaginary object gestures (e.g., pretending to hold an imaginary toothbrush). To determine if children's symbolic skill is sufficiently flexible to allow them to use gestures other than those spontaneously produced in the first task, in the second task children were asked to imitate, for each object, a gesture modeled by an experimenter. The modeled gesture was different from the one the child performed on the first task (e.g., if the child used a body part gesture to represent a particular object, the experimenter modeled an imaginary object gesture for that object). Ability to imitate modeled gestures was positively related to age but was also influenced by the symbolic mode of gesture. 3-year-olds could not imitate imaginary object gestures as well as body part gestures, suggesting that young preschoolers have difficulty performing symbolic acts that exceed their symbolic level even when the acts are modeled. Results from both tasks provide strong evidence for a developmental progression from concrete body part to more abstract imaginary object gestural representations during the preschool years.
为了探究在没有真实物体的情况下学龄前儿童手势表征的象征性质,48名儿童(16名3岁、4岁和5岁儿童)参与了两项任务。在第一项任务中,他们被要求假装使用8种常见物体(例如,“假装用牙刷刷牙”)。手势表征的象征性质存在与年龄相关的发展进程。3岁和4岁儿童大多使用身体部位手势(例如,用伸出的手指当作牙刷),而5岁儿童则使用想象物体手势(例如,假装拿着一把想象中的牙刷)。为了确定儿童的象征技能是否足够灵活,使他们能够使用除第一项任务中自发产生的手势之外的其他手势,在第二项任务中,要求儿童针对每个物体模仿实验者示范的一个手势。示范手势与儿童在第一项任务中做出的手势不同(例如,如果儿童用身体部位手势来表示某个特定物体,实验者就为该物体示范一个想象物体手势)。模仿示范手势的能力与年龄呈正相关,但也受到手势象征模式的影响。3岁儿童模仿想象物体手势的能力不如模仿身体部位手势的能力,这表明即使有示范,年幼的学龄前儿童在执行超出其象征水平的象征行为时仍有困难。两项任务的结果都为学龄前儿童从具体的身体部位手势到更抽象的想象物体手势表征的发展进程提供了有力证据。