Nuttall F Q
Section of Endocrinology, Metabolism and Nutrition, VA Medical Center, Minneapolis, MN 55417.
Diabetes. 1993 Apr;42(4):503-8. doi: 10.2337/diab.42.4.503.
It generally is accepted that a diet high in fiber, particularly soluble fiber, is useful in the management of the plasma glucose concentration in individuals with diabetes. This is one of the reasons several national diabetes associations have recommended that diabetic individuals ingest a diet high in fiber-containing foods. However, more recent data obtained in carefully controlled studies with more definitive end points, indicate this may not be the case. It has been shown clearly that addition of water-soluble, gel-forming fiber in the form of guar gum and perhaps gum tragacanth to an ingested glucose solution or to a mixed meal will reduce the expected rise in glucose concentration. This has been demonstrated in both normal subjects and subjects with IDDM and NIDDM. However, it is only observed when large amounts of fiber are added. The fiber also must be mixed with the administered glucose or food. Other less viscous soluble fiber sources such as the pectins and psyllium powder are not effective. In long-term, well-controlled trials, guar gum, pectin, beet fiber, or cereal bran fiber ingested with meals has been of little or no value in controlling the plasma glucose concentration in individuals with NIDDM. Several studies have been conducted in which a high-carbohydrate diet has been reported to reduce the plasma glucose concentration. In these diets, foods with a high fiber content have been emphasized. In general, they were not well controlled, and several confounding variables such as weight loss, decreased food energy intake, different food sources with potential for differences in starch digestibility, and decreased dietary fat content were present.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
一般认为,高纤维饮食,尤其是可溶性纤维饮食,对控制糖尿病患者的血糖浓度有益。这就是几个国家糖尿病协会建议糖尿病患者摄入富含纤维食物的原因之一。然而,最近在终点更明确的严格对照研究中获得的数据表明情况可能并非如此。已清楚表明,在摄入的葡萄糖溶液或混合餐中添加瓜尔胶形式的水溶性、形成凝胶的纤维,或许还有西黄蓍胶,会降低预期的血糖浓度升高。这在正常受试者以及1型糖尿病和2型糖尿病患者中都得到了证实。然而,只有在添加大量纤维时才会观察到这种情况。纤维还必须与给予的葡萄糖或食物混合。其他粘性较小的可溶性纤维来源,如果胶和车前子粉,并无效果。在长期严格对照试验中,用餐时摄入的瓜尔胶、果胶、甜菜纤维或麦麸纤维对控制2型糖尿病患者的血糖浓度几乎没有价值或毫无价值。已有多项研究报道高碳水化合物饮食可降低血糖浓度。在这些饮食中,强调了高纤维含量的食物。总体而言,这些研究控制不佳,存在一些混杂变量,如体重减轻、食物能量摄入减少、淀粉消化率可能存在差异的不同食物来源以及饮食脂肪含量降低。(摘要截选于250字)