Levinson W, Stiles W B, Inui T S, Engle R
Good Samaritan Hospital and Medical Center, Portland, OR 97210.
Med Care. 1993 Apr;31(4):285-95. doi: 10.1097/00005650-199304000-00001.
In this study, the nature of practicing physicians' "frustrating" visits was explored and a guide to help physicians identify problems in communicating with patients was developed. The study included 1,076 practicing physicians who attended a voluntary workshop on physician-patient communication. The physicians were from multiple specialties and diverse work settings geographically dispersed throughout the United States. The method included development of a preliminary item pool (descriptions of frustrating patients and occasions) by experienced physicians and teachers of medical communication, additions/deletions/revisions of items within the pool, empirical analyses to reduce redundancy and group-like items, and construct validation of the final 25-item questionnaire. Factor analysis was used to identify subscales. Physicians most often attributed communication problems to the patient rather than to their own limitations. Seven types of communication problems (subscales) were identified, including: 1) lack of trust/agreement, 2) too many problems, 3) feeling distressed, 4) lack of understanding, 5) lack of adherence, 6) demanding/controlling patient, and 7) special problems. Primary care physicians reported greater problems than specialists on four subscales. Physicians practicing in health maintenance organizations reported greater problems than physicians in fee-for-service practice on five subscales. Seven sources of frustration physicians experience in their work with patients were identified. Understanding these frustrations will allow physicians to reflect on their own experiences and potentially improve the quality of their patient visits.
在本研究中,探讨了执业医师“令人沮丧”的就诊情况的本质,并制定了一份指南以帮助医师识别与患者沟通中的问题。该研究纳入了1076名参加医患沟通自愿研讨会的执业医师。这些医师来自多个专业领域,工作地点各异,在地理上分散于美国各地。研究方法包括由经验丰富的医师和医学沟通教师制定一个初步的项目库(对令人沮丧的患者和就诊场合的描述),对库中的项目进行增减/修订,进行实证分析以减少冗余和类似项目,并对最终的25项问卷进行结构验证。使用因子分析来识别子量表。医师们最常将沟通问题归咎于患者而非自身的局限性。识别出了七种沟通问题(子量表),包括:1)缺乏信任/共识,2)问题过多,3)感到苦恼,4)缺乏理解,5)缺乏依从性,6)要求过高/控制欲强的患者,以及7)特殊问题。在四个子量表上,初级保健医师报告的问题比专科医师更多。在五个子量表上,在健康维护组织执业的医师报告的问题比按服务收费执业的医师更多。识别出了医师在与患者工作中经历的七种沮丧来源。了解这些沮丧情绪将使医师能够反思自己的经历,并有可能提高他们的患者就诊质量。