Harris A, Ismail I, Dilly S, Maxwell J D
Department of Medicine, St. George's Hospital, London.
J R Coll Physicians Lond. 1993 Apr;27(2):116-8.
The overall autopsy rate (excluding coroner's autopsies) at a large teaching district general hospital over a four year period was 16.5%, but individual rates for ten general physicians varied from 5% to 35%. During this period, the mean autopsy rate for general medicine (14%) was significantly lower than rates for cardiology (21%), geriatrics (23%) and paediatrics (36%), but similar to general surgery (13%). Autopsies were widely perceived as being of benefit to education and research, but physicians were often unaware of their value for confirming the diagnosis and for clinical audit, and over-estimated their actual autopsy rates on average by 50%. High rates (18-30%) were associated with consultants who had a definite policy regarding autopsies and had made this clear to their junior staff. Low rates (6-10%) obtained where there was no consultant policy on autopsies, and were frequently attributed by the consultant physicians to failure by their junior staff. Physicians should be more aware of the value of autopsies, and should take responsibility for increasing and monitoring autopsy requests to improve clinical audit, quality assurance and medical education.
一家大型教学区综合医院在四年期间的总体尸检率(不包括验尸官进行的尸检)为16.5%,但十位普通内科医生的个人尸检率从5%到35%不等。在此期间,普通内科的平均尸检率(14%)显著低于心脏病学(21%)、老年医学(23%)和儿科学(36%)的尸检率,但与普通外科(13%)相似。尸检被广泛认为对教育和研究有益,但医生们往往没有意识到尸检在确诊和临床审计方面的价值,并且平均高估了他们实际的尸检率50%。高尸检率(18 - 30%)与那些对尸检有明确政策并已向其下级员工阐明的顾问医生有关。在没有顾问医生关于尸检的政策的情况下,尸检率较低(6 - 10%),而且顾问医生经常将其归因于下级员工的失职。医生们应该更加意识到尸检的价值,并应负责增加和监督尸检申请,以改善临床审计、质量保证和医学教育。