van Heeringen C, Jannes C
Department of Psychiatry, University Hospital, Gent, Belgium.
Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. 1993 Apr;28(2):66-70. doi: 10.1007/BF00802094.
The gender-specific rate of attempted suicide, calculated from hospital admission data, was significantly lower in 1990 than in 1986 in females and, when age is taken into account, in females younger than 35 and in males younger than 25 years. The incidence of suicide attempts seen by general practitioners also decreased. Indications for rejection of the artefact hypothesis as explanation for this decrease have been investigated. It was shown that the decrease in the prevalence was found at local and national levels and was not the result of a decrease in referrals to general hospitals. Moreover, the decrease in the rate was associated with an increase in the use of outpatient mental health facilities in females and with a trend to increase in the 15-24 age group. The number of suicide attempts referred by Community Mental Health Services to the general hospital and the suicide rate in out-patients remained constant during the study period. The findings do not support the artefact hypothesis but indicate that there was a real decrease in the rate of attempted suicide. Moreover, the findings suggest that out-patient treatment can be efficacious in the primary prevention of suicidal behaviour.
根据医院入院数据计算得出的特定性别自杀未遂率,在1990年时,女性低于1986年,且在考虑年龄因素时,35岁以下女性以及25岁以下男性的自杀未遂率也低于1986年。全科医生诊治的自杀未遂发生率也有所下降。对作为该下降原因的人为假象假说被否定的迹象进行了调查。结果表明,患病率的下降在地方和国家层面均有体现,并非转至综合医院的病例减少所致。此外,自杀未遂率的下降与女性门诊心理健康服务使用的增加以及15 - 24岁年龄组的上升趋势相关。在研究期间,社区心理健康服务机构转至综合医院的自杀未遂病例数以及门诊患者的自杀率保持稳定。这些发现不支持人为假象假说,而是表明自杀未遂率确实有所下降。此外,这些发现表明门诊治疗在自杀行为的一级预防中可能有效。