Savage C, Vincent P, Leclerc H
Laboratoire de Bactériologie, CHU, Faculté de Médecine, Lille, France.
Zentralbl Bakteriol. 1993 Feb;278(1):49-57. doi: 10.1016/s0934-8840(11)80278-1.
In order to evaluate the suitability of serology in the diagnosis of tuberculosis the Mycobacterium tuberculosis anti-sulpholipidic IV IgG were assayed, using the ELISA test, in 41 healthy controls, 121 hospitalized but non-tuberculous patients and 142 tuberculous persons including 46 cured patients. At the 150 and 300 O.D. thresholds proposed in previous studies using the same antigen, the specificity was 88.27% and 98.76%, respectively, and the sensitivity 25% and 11.45%. These results were not related to different potential factors (age, background, associated pathology) but to infection intensity which enhanced the IgG reaction. This may explain discrepancies observed in previous studies made under other epidemiological conditions. Therefore, in this European population from a universitarity hospital, it appears that too many tuberculous patients have such a low IgG reaction that serology cannot be an effective assay in the diagnostic step.
为了评估血清学在结核病诊断中的适用性,采用酶联免疫吸附试验(ELISA)检测了41名健康对照者、121名住院但非结核患者以及142名结核患者(包括46名已治愈患者)的结核分枝杆菌抗磷脂酰肌醇IV IgG。在先前使用相同抗原的研究中提出的150和300光密度阈值下,特异性分别为88.27%和98.76%,敏感性分别为25%和11.45%。这些结果与不同的潜在因素(年龄、背景、相关病理)无关,而是与增强IgG反应的感染强度有关。这可能解释了在其他流行病学条件下进行的先前研究中观察到的差异。因此,在这家大学医院的欧洲人群中,似乎有太多结核患者的IgG反应很低,以至于血清学在诊断步骤中无法成为一种有效的检测方法。