Susser E, Fennig S, Jandorf L, Amador X, Bromet E
New York State Psychiatric Institute, NY 10032, USA.
Am J Psychiatry. 1995 Dec;152(12):1743-8. doi: 10.1176/ajp.152.12.1743.
This study investigated acute and nonacute brief psychoses. On the basis of previous work, the authors proposed that 1) acute brief psychoses occur predominantly in females, 2) they often do not conform to the diagnoses of DSM-III-R, 3) they are temporally stable, and 4) nonacute brief psychoses do not share these distinctive features.
The data are from a follow-up study of 221 first-admission patients with affective and nonaffective psychoses. Patients were given extensive assessments at initial evaluation, 6-month follow-up, and 24-month follow-up. The research team made consensus ratings of the presence of psychosis, DSM-III-R diagnosis, mode of onset of disorder, and course of disorder. Brief psychoses were defined by a diagnosis of nonaffective psychosis at the initial evaluation and a rating of full remission at 6-month follow-up; acute brief psychoses met the additional criterion of acute onset as defined by ICD-10.
Twenty (9%) of the 221 psychoses were brief psychoses. Only seven (3%) were acute brief psychoses, but among these, six occurred in women, five were undiagnosable, and none had evolved into an affective disorder or a chronic disorder by the time of the 24-month follow-up. The 13 nonacute brief psychoses did not exhibit distinctive features, and five of them later evolved into chronic disorders.
Acute brief psychoses emerged as a highly distinctive and temporally stable form of psychosis that may merit a separate diagnostic classification. The more numerous nonacute brief psychoses may represent mild forms of nonaffective psychoses such as schizophrenia.
本研究对急性和非急性短暂性精神病进行了调查。基于之前的研究工作,作者提出:1)急性短暂性精神病主要发生在女性中;2)它们常常不符合《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第三版修订本(DSM-III-R)的诊断标准;3)它们在时间上具有稳定性;4)非急性短暂性精神病不具备这些独特特征。
数据来自对221例首次入院的情感性和非情感性精神病患者的随访研究。患者在初次评估、6个月随访和24个月随访时接受了广泛评估。研究团队对精神病的存在、DSM-III-R诊断、疾病的起病方式和病程进行了一致性评定。短暂性精神病的定义为初次评估时诊断为非情感性精神病且6个月随访时评定为完全缓解;急性短暂性精神病还符合国际疾病分类第十版(ICD-10)所定义的急性起病这一额外标准。
221例精神病中有20例(9%)为短暂性精神病。只有7例(3%)是急性短暂性精神病,但其中6例发生在女性中,5例无法诊断,到24个月随访时,没有一例发展为情感性障碍或慢性障碍。13例非急性短暂性精神病未表现出独特特征,其中5例后来发展为慢性障碍。
急性短暂性精神病是一种高度独特且在时间上具有稳定性的精神病形式,可能值得单独进行诊断分类。数量较多的非急性短暂性精神病可能代表非情感性精神病如精神分裂症的轻度形式。