Pringle M, Rothera I
Department of General Practice, Medical School, Queen's Medical Centre, Nottingham.
BMJ. 1996 Apr 27;312(7038):1080-2. doi: 10.1136/bmj.312.7038.1080.
To assess the feasibility of recording patient ethnicity in primary care using the Office of Population Censuses and Surveys classification.
A descriptive intervention study and attitude survey in random samples of adults and primary care staff in randomly selected practices.
Eight practices in Lincolnshire and seven in Leicester.
When patients were asked their ethnicity by general practitioners, nurses, or receptionists data were collected for 863 of a possible 880 patients. Of 750 patients sent a questionnaire about their attitudes towards the collection of such data 489 responded. Ninety five primary care staff completed a similar questionnaire.
Time taken to record a patient's ethnicity; attitudes of patients and staff towards such recording, including who should ask, who can respond for others, and whether data can be shared with secondary care.
Recording the data took less than a minute for three quarters of patients, but even this would need an average of a week of receptionist time per general practitioner. 72% of patients and 57% of staff agreed that ethnic data could be shared with secondary care, and 73% of patients and 60% of staff felt that the data should probably be collected in general practice.
Ethnicity recording in general practice is feasible and acceptable. Nevertheless, the role of ethnic data in assessing health need in primary care, an adequate recording system, and evidence that recording offers benefits greater than the costs need to be established.
使用人口普查和调查办公室分类法评估在初级医疗保健中记录患者种族的可行性。
对随机抽取的医疗机构中的成年患者和初级医疗保健工作人员随机样本进行描述性干预研究和态度调查。
林肯郡的8家医疗机构和莱斯特的7家医疗机构。
当全科医生、护士或接待员询问患者种族时,在可能的880名患者中收集了863名患者的数据。在向750名患者发送了关于他们对收集此类数据态度的问卷中,489名患者做出了回应。95名初级医疗保健工作人员完成了一份类似的问卷。
记录患者种族所需的时间;患者和工作人员对这种记录的态度,包括应由谁询问、谁可以代表他人回答以及数据是否可以与二级医疗保健机构共享。
四分之三的患者记录数据用时不到一分钟,但即便如此,每位全科医生平均仍需要接待员一周的时间。72%的患者和57%的工作人员同意种族数据可以与二级医疗保健机构共享,73%的患者和60%的工作人员认为在全科医疗中可能应该收集这些数据。
在全科医疗中记录种族是可行且可接受的。然而,种族数据在评估初级医疗保健中的健康需求方面的作用、一个适当的记录系统以及记录带来的益处大于成本的证据仍有待确立。