Dupont W D, Plummer W D
Department of Preventive Medicine, Vanderbilt University School of Medicine, Nashville, Tennessee 37232-2637, USA.
Cancer. 1996 Jun 1;77(11):2193-9. doi: 10.1002/(SICI)1097-0142(19960601)77:11<2193::AID-CNCR2>3.0.CO;2-R.
Relative risks are the most common statistics used to quantify the risk of mortal or morbid outcomes associated with different patient groups and therapeutic interventions. However, absolute risks are of greater value of both patient and physician in making clinical decisions.
The relationship between relative and absolute risks is explained using graphical aids. A program to estimate absolute risks from relative risks is available on the internet (see ftp://ftp.vanderbilt.edu/pub/biostat/absrisk+ ++.txt). This program uses a competing hazards model of morbidity and mortality to derive these estimates.
When a patient's absolute risk is low, it can be approximated by multiplying her relative risk by the absolute risk in the reference population. This approximation fails for higher absolute risks. The relationship between relative and absolute risk can vary dramatically for different diseases. This is illustrated by breast cancer morbidity and cardiovascular mortality in American women. The accuracy of absolute risk estimates will be affected by the accuracy of relative risk estimates, by the appropriateness of the reference groups used to calculate relative risks, by the stability of cross-sectional, age-specific morbidity and mortality rates over time, by the influence of individual risk factors on multiple causes of mortality, and by the extent to which relative risks may vary over time.
Valid absolute risk estimates are valuable when making treatment decisions. They can often be obtained over time intervals of 10 to 20 years when the corresponding relative risk estimates have been accurately determined.
相对风险是用于量化不同患者群体和治疗干预相关的死亡或发病结局风险的最常用统计指标。然而,绝对风险在临床决策中对患者和医生都具有更大的价值。
使用图形辅助工具解释相对风险和绝对风险之间的关系。可在互联网上获取一个从相对风险估计绝对风险的程序(见ftp://ftp.vanderbilt.edu/pub/biostat/absrisk+++.txt)。该程序使用发病率和死亡率的竞争风险模型来得出这些估计值。
当患者的绝对风险较低时,可通过将其相对风险乘以参考人群中的绝对风险来近似估计。对于较高的绝对风险,这种近似方法不适用。相对风险与绝对风险之间的关系在不同疾病中可能有很大差异。美国女性的乳腺癌发病率和心血管死亡率就说明了这一点。绝对风险估计的准确性将受到相对风险估计的准确性、用于计算相对风险的参考组的适当性、横断面年龄特异性发病率和死亡率随时间的稳定性、个体风险因素对多种死亡原因的影响以及相对风险随时间变化程度的影响。
有效的绝对风险估计在做出治疗决策时很有价值。当相应的相对风险估计已准确确定时,通常可以在10至20年的时间间隔内获得绝对风险估计。