Vogel G W, Barker K, Gibbons P, Thurmond A
Psychopharmacology (Berl). 1976 May 5;47(1):81-6. doi: 10.1007/BF00428706.
The effects of oral, bedtime triazolam 0.5 mg and flurazepam 30 mg, on the laboratory sleep of 12 insomniacs were compared in a double blind, crossover study. A 22 consecutive night schedule was used: Nts. 1--2 placebo; 3--6 first drug; 7--8 placebo; 9--14 no drugs; 15--16 placebo; 17--20 second drug; 21--22 placebo. In 6 Ss first drug was triazolam and second drug was flurazepam. In the other 6 Ss the drug order was reversed. Effects on sleep were assessed objectively by conventional EEG/EOG/EMG sleep recordings and subjectively by questionnaires administered each morning. Side or toxic effects were assessed by physical exams, clinical lab tests, and twice daily questionnaires. During their administration the two drugs were practically indistinguishable in their effects. Both significantly reduced objective and subjective measures of insomnia, such as total wake time and sleep latency. On discontinuation the drugs differentially affected sleep, e.g., on the first post flurazepam night total sleep time was significantly more than baseline whereas on first post triazolam night, total sleep time was significantly less than baseline. There were no remarkable side or toxic effects with either drug.
在一项双盲交叉研究中,比较了口服0.5毫克三唑仑和30毫克氟西泮对12名失眠症患者实验室睡眠的影响。采用连续22晚的方案:第1 - 2晚服用安慰剂;第3 - 6晚服用第一种药物;第7 - 8晚服用安慰剂;第9 - 14晚不服药;第15 - 16晚服用安慰剂;第17 - 20晚服用第二种药物;第21 - 22晚服用安慰剂。6名受试者第一种药物为三唑仑,第二种药物为氟西泮。另外6名受试者药物顺序相反。通过传统的脑电图/眼电图/肌电图睡眠记录客观评估对睡眠的影响,每天早晨通过问卷调查主观评估。通过体格检查、临床实验室检查和每日两次的问卷调查评估副作用或毒性作用。在给药期间,两种药物的效果几乎无法区分。两者均显著降低了失眠的客观和主观指标,如总觉醒时间和睡眠潜伏期。停药后,两种药物对睡眠的影响不同,例如,在停用氟西泮后的第一个晚上,总睡眠时间显著高于基线,而在停用三唑仑后的第一个晚上,总睡眠时间显著低于基线。两种药物均未出现明显的副作用或毒性作用。