Thomson M, Connor S, Bennett S, D'Alessandro U, Milligan P, Aikins M, Langerock P, Jawara M, Greenwood B
Medical Research Council Laboratories, Fajara, The Gambia.
Soc Sci Med. 1996 Jul;43(1):101-12. doi: 10.1016/0277-9536(95)00346-0.
Insecticide-impregnated bednets are now widely accepted as an important tool in reducing malaria-related deaths in children in Africa. Defining the circumstances in which net treatment programmes are likely to be effective is essential to a rational development of this control strategy. In The Gambia a National Impregnated Bednet Programme was introduced into the primary health care system in 1992. Prior to its introduction baseline epidemiological and entomological studies were conducted throughout the country. These studies showed that in areas where mosquito biting nuisance was high, people protected themselves with bednets and that where mosquito densities (and therefore bednet usage) was low malaria prevalence rates were relatively high. Since the national programme is designed to assist only those people who already own a bednet (by providing the insecticide) an understanding of the factors which determine bednet ownership is needed to help evaluate the programme's effectiveness and provide guidelines for increasing bednet usage. Village scale bednet usage rates and malaria prevalence rates obtained from the baseline survey were correlated with certain geographical variables: dominant ethnic group, area, habitat, distance from the River Gambia and distance from the 'bluffline' (the interface between the sandstone soils and alluvial soils which border the river system). In a multiple regression analysis, bednet usage was independently associated with area (P < 0.001), ethnic group (P = 0.010), habitat (P = 0.006) and distance from the river (P = 0.013). A negative association of bednet usage with malaria prevalence persisted after allowing for the other variables. Malaria prevalence was not independently associated with area, ethnic group, habitat or distance from the river. Our analysis showed that the impregnated bednet programme is likely to be most effective in villages which are sited near to or on the alluvial soils in the middle and lower river zones. These villages, which were originally settled for easy access to the river (for transport) and its swampy margins (for rice production) are within the flight distance of mosquitoes that have their breeding sites on the poorly drained alluvial soils. Variation in malaria prevalence rates (after bednet usage has been taken into account) may be related to factors such as poverty and access to health care, and/or to localized differences in the ecology of The Gambia, which determine the duration and intensity of transmission. If the National Bednet Programme is to be effective throughout The Gambia it is vital to develop promotional activities which will encourage bednet usage in areas where nuisance biting by mosquitoes is low.
用杀虫剂处理过的蚊帐现已被广泛视为减少非洲儿童疟疾相关死亡的一项重要工具。明确蚊帐处理项目可能有效的情况对于合理制定这一防控策略至关重要。在冈比亚,1992年一项全国性的浸药蚊帐项目被引入初级卫生保健系统。在该项目引入之前,在全国范围内开展了基线流行病学和昆虫学研究。这些研究表明,在蚊虫叮咬困扰严重的地区,人们会使用蚊帐保护自己;而在蚊虫密度较低(因此蚊帐使用率也低)的地区,疟疾患病率相对较高。由于国家项目旨在仅帮助那些已经拥有蚊帐的人(通过提供杀虫剂),所以需要了解决定蚊帐拥有情况的因素,以帮助评估该项目的成效,并为提高蚊帐使用率提供指导方针。从基线调查中获得的村庄层面的蚊帐使用率和疟疾患病率与某些地理变量相关:主要族群、地区、栖息地、距冈比亚河的距离以及距“断崖线”(砂岩土壤与毗邻河流系统的冲积土壤之间的界面)的距离。在多元回归分析中,蚊帐使用率与地区(P < 0.001)、族群(P = 0.010)、栖息地(P = 0.006)和距河流的距离(P = 0.013)独立相关。在考虑其他变量后,蚊帐使用率与疟疾患病率之间的负相关关系依然存在。疟疾患病率与地区、族群、栖息地或距河流的距离并无独立关联。我们的分析表明,浸药蚊帐项目在位于中、下游河区靠近冲积土壤或位于冲积土壤之上的村庄可能最为有效。这些村庄最初是为了便于靠近河流(用于运输)及其沼泽边缘(用于水稻种植)而建,处于在排水不良的冲积土壤上有繁殖地的蚊虫飞行距离之内。(在考虑蚊帐使用率之后)疟疾患病率的差异可能与贫困和获得医疗保健的机会等因素有关,和/或与冈比亚生态的局部差异有关,这些差异决定了传播的持续时间和强度。如果全国蚊帐项目要在冈比亚全境有效,开展宣传活动以鼓励在蚊虫叮咬困扰较低的地区使用蚊帐至关重要。