Fasano M L, Sand T, Brubakk A O, Kruszewski P, Bordini C, Sjaastad O
Department of Neurology, Trondheim University Hospitals, Norway.
Clin Auton Res. 1996 Oct;6(5):249-53. doi: 10.1007/BF02556295.
The reproducibility of the cold pressor test was studied in healthy subjects. A non-invasive method was utilized for estimating beat-to-beat arterial blood pressure (BP) and heart rate (HR). The study population of 17 healthy volunteers consisted of two groups. In the first group (Group 1, n = 11), a 1-min test was performed three times during the same day. In the second group (Group 2, n = 6), a 2-min test was repeated at the same time of the day on three consecutive days. In both groups, the test response was defined as the 46- to 60-s mean, minus the prestimulus 15 s baseline mean. In Group 1, a fair test-retest reliability was observed for the systolic BP response (intraclass correlation coefficient R = 0.57). Large intraindividual HR and diastolic BP variabilities were found. The intraindividual testretest difference in Group 1 ranged from -8 to 11 beats/min (SD = 4.3, R = 0.49) for the HR, from -16 to 13 mmHg (SD = 6.3) for systolic BP, and form -21 to 20 mmHg (SD = 9.7, R = 0.23) for diastolic BP. Even larger variability was observed when the test was repeated on different days (Group 2). Thus, the maxim that the response pattern to the cold pressor test is fairly constant for each individual may not be true. It does not seem to be advisable to use the results from one solitary cold pressor test. The use of replicated measurements and large sample sizes in comparative studies to compensate for the low to moderate reliability of the cold pressor test is recommended.
在健康受试者中研究了冷加压试验的可重复性。采用一种非侵入性方法来估计逐搏动脉血压(BP)和心率(HR)。17名健康志愿者的研究人群分为两组。在第一组(第1组,n = 11)中,在同一天进行了3次1分钟的测试。在第二组(第2组,n = 6)中,在连续三天的同一天时间重复进行2分钟的测试。在两组中,测试反应定义为46至60秒的平均值减去刺激前15秒的基线平均值。在第1组中,观察到收缩压反应具有尚可的重测信度(组内相关系数R = 0.57)。发现个体心率和舒张压存在较大变异性。第1组个体内重测差异范围为:心率为-8至11次/分钟(标准差= 4.3,R = 0.49),收缩压为-16至13 mmHg(标准差= 6.3),舒张压为-21至20 mmHg(标准差= 9.7,R = 0.23)。当在不同日期重复测试时(第2组),观察到的变异性甚至更大。因此,对于每个个体而言冷加压试验的反应模式相当恒定这一准则可能并不正确。仅使用一次冷加压试验的结果似乎并不可取。建议在比较研究中使用重复测量和大样本量以弥补冷加压试验低至中等的可靠性。