Tompkins R L
Department of Anthropology, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque 87131, USA.
Am J Phys Anthropol. 1996 Jan;99(1):79-102. doi: 10.1002/(SICI)1096-8644(199601)99:1<79::AID-AJPA5>3.0.CO;2-V.
Using dental X-rays, the calcification of various teeth was compared between samples of black southern Africans, white French-Canadians, and prehistoric Native Americans sharing the same stage of calcification of a specified "reference tooth." The French-Canadians have markedly delayed relative development of the M3 compared to the Africans. They also appear delayed in their M2 development compared to both the Africans and Amerindians. While no difference in relative mandibular canine development is found between the African and French-Canadian males, French-Canadian females are advanced over the African females. Prehistoric Native Americans may be delayed in mandibular central incisor development compared to French-Canadians. These results are in general accord with other studies of variability in dental development between Africans/African Americans, Europeans/European Americans, and Native Americans, and demonstrate that population differences in ages of eruption are attributable in part to differences in relative dental development. Two potentially falsifiable hypotheses concerning the significance of population variability in relative dental development are discussed: 1) the variability (at least for molars) is associated with the amount of space in the jaws for developing teeth, 2) the variability is due to population differences in the timing of dental and skeletal development.
利用牙科X光,对来自南非黑人、法裔加拿大白人以及处于特定“参考牙齿”相同钙化阶段的史前美洲原住民样本的各类牙齿钙化情况进行了比较。与非洲人相比,法裔加拿大人的M3相对发育明显延迟。与非洲人和美洲印第安人相比,他们的M2发育似乎也延迟了。虽然非洲男性和法裔加拿大男性在下颌尖牙相对发育上没有差异,但法裔加拿大女性比非洲女性发育得更快。与法裔加拿大人相比,史前美洲原住民在下颌中切牙发育上可能会延迟。这些结果总体上与其他关于非洲人/非裔美国人、欧洲人/欧裔美国人以及美洲原住民牙齿发育变异性的研究一致,并表明出牙年龄的人群差异部分归因于相对牙齿发育的差异。讨论了两个关于人群相对牙齿发育变异性意义的可证伪假设:1)变异性(至少对于磨牙而言)与颌骨中牙齿发育空间的大小有关;2)变异性是由于牙齿和骨骼发育时间上的人群差异所致。