Horner K, Devlin H, Alsop C W, Hodgkinson I M, Adams J E
Turner Dental School, University Dental Hospital of Manchester, UK.
Br J Radiol. 1996 Nov;69(827):1019-25. doi: 10.1259/0007-1285-69-827-1019.
A considerable amount of work has been performed on methods of detecting individuals with low bone mass at an early stage. Some researchers have considered if dental radiographs could have a role in the detection of individuals with osteoporosis. A basic requirement for this would be that bone mass in the jaw relates significantly to that of other skeletal sites in which osteoporosis is a significant problem. The first aim of this study was to investigate the relationship between mandibular bone mineral density (BMD) and that of other skeletal sites commonly used for bone densitometry in the detection of osteoporosis. The second aim was to assess the validity of mandibular BMD as a predictor of BMD in these other sites. 40 edentulous females underwent dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) of the lumbar spine (L2-L4), DXA of the right femoral neck, single photon absorptiometry (SPA) of the proximal and distal forearm and DXA of the mandible. Significant correlations were observed between BMD in the mandibular body, ramus and symphysis and all other skeletal sites (p < 0.02). Five patients (12.5%) had age matched Z-scores of -1.0 or lower in all three non-mandibular sites (lumbar spine, femoral neck and forearm). Using these patients as the proportion of the population with a positive finding of "low bone mass", the sensitivity and specificity of mandibular BMD in predicting low bone mass for these patients was determined. Where a diagnostic threshold for low mandibular BMD was set at one standard deviation below the mean, the mandibular body BMD measurement gave high sensitivity (0.8) and specificity (0.97), the symphysis BMD low sensitivity (0.4) but a high specificity (0.77), while the ramus BMD had a moderate level of sensitivity (0.6) and high specificity (0.91). It is concluded that mandibular BMD assessed by DXA correlates significantly with BMD measurements of other important skeletal sites. The higher correlation coefficients and the greater sensitivity and specificity for the body of mandible suggest that this site should be used for any potential clinical application of dental radiographs in detection of osteoporosis.
在早期检测低骨量个体的方法方面已经开展了大量工作。一些研究人员思考了牙科X光片在骨质疏松症个体检测中是否能发挥作用。对此的一个基本要求是,颌骨中的骨量与骨质疏松症是一个重大问题的其他骨骼部位的骨量显著相关。本研究的首要目的是调查下颌骨骨密度(BMD)与用于骨质疏松症检测的骨密度测量的其他骨骼部位的骨密度之间的关系。第二个目的是评估下颌骨BMD作为这些其他部位BMD预测指标的有效性。40名无牙女性接受了腰椎(L2 - L4)的双能X线吸收法(DXA)、右股骨颈的DXA、前臂近端和远端的单光子吸收法(SPA)以及下颌骨的DXA。在下颌体、下颌支和下颌联合处的BMD与所有其他骨骼部位之间观察到显著相关性(p < 0.02)。五名患者(12.5%)在所有三个非下颌骨部位(腰椎、股骨颈和前臂)的年龄匹配Z值为 -1.0或更低。以这些患者作为“低骨量”阳性发现人群的比例,确定了下颌骨BMD预测这些患者低骨量的敏感性和特异性。当下颌骨BMD的诊断阈值设定为低于平均值一个标准差时,下颌体BMD测量具有高敏感性(0.8)和高特异性(0.97),下颌联合处BMD敏感性低(0.4)但特异性高(0.77),而下颌支BMD具有中等水平的敏感性(0.6)和高特异性(0.91)。得出的结论是,通过DXA评估的下颌骨BMD与其他重要骨骼部位的BMD测量值显著相关。下颌体更高的相关系数以及更高的敏感性和特异性表明,在牙科X光片检测骨质疏松症的任何潜在临床应用中都应使用该部位。