Hutchinson G, Takei N, Fahy T A, Bhugra D, Gilvarry C, Moran P, Mallett R, Sham P, Leff J, Murray R M
Department of Psychological Medicine, Institute of Psychiatry, London.
Br J Psychiatry. 1996 Dec;169(6):776-80. doi: 10.1192/bjp.169.6.776.
The high rate of schizophrenia among the second-generation African-Caribbean population in Britain has prompted much concern and speculation. Sugarman and Craufurd have reported that the morbid risk in the siblings of second-generation African-Caribbean schizophrenic patients was unusually high compared with that of the siblings of White patients.
We sought to replicate these findings by comparing the morbid risk for schizophrenia in the first-degree relatives of 111 White and 73 African-Caribbean psychotic probands. The latter comprised 35 first-generation (born in the Caribbean) and 38 second-generation (born in Britain) probands.
The morbid risk for schizophrenia was similar for the parents and siblings of White and first-generation African-Caribbean patients, and for the parents of the second-generation African-Caribbean probands. However, the siblings of second-generation African-Caribbean psychotic probands had a morbid risk for schizophrenia that was seven times that of their White counterparts (P = 0.007); similarly, the siblings of second-generation African-Caribbean schizophrenic probands had a morbid risk for schizophrenia that was four times that of their White counterparts (P = 0.05).
These findings replicate those of the earlier report of Sugarman and Craufurd, and suggest either that the second-generation African-Caribbean population in Britain is particularly vulnerable to some environmental risk factors for schizophrenia, or that some environmental factors act selectively on this population in Britain.
英国第二代非洲 - 加勒比裔人群中精神分裂症的高发病率引发了诸多关注和猜测。苏格曼和克劳福德报告称,与白人患者的兄弟姐妹相比,第二代非洲 - 加勒比裔精神分裂症患者的兄弟姐妹患该病的风险异常高。
我们试图通过比较111名白人和73名非洲 - 加勒比裔精神病先证者的一级亲属患精神分裂症的风险来重现这些发现。后者包括35名第一代(出生于加勒比地区)和38名第二代(出生于英国)先证者。
白人和第一代非洲 - 加勒比裔患者的父母及兄弟姐妹,以及第二代非洲 - 加勒比裔先证者的父母患精神分裂症的风险相似。然而,第二代非洲 - 加勒比裔精神病先证者的兄弟姐妹患精神分裂症的风险是白人兄弟姐妹的7倍(P = 0.007);同样,第二代非洲 - 加勒比裔精神分裂症先证者的兄弟姐妹患精神分裂症的风险是白人兄弟姐妹的4倍(P = 0.05)。
这些发现重现了苏格曼和克劳福德早期报告的结果,并表明要么英国的第二代非洲 - 加勒比裔人群特别容易受到某些精神分裂症环境风险因素的影响,要么某些环境因素在英国对这一人群有选择性地起作用。