Winkleby M A, Taylor C B, Jatulis D, Fortmann S P
Stanford Center for Research in Disease Prevention, Stanford University School of Medicine, Palo Alto, Calif 94304-1825, USA.
Am J Public Health. 1996 Dec;86(12):1773-9. doi: 10.2105/ajph.86.12.1773.
This study examined long-term effects of a health-education intervention trial to reduce the risk of cardiovascular disease.
Surveys were conducted in California in two treatment and two control cities at baseline (1979/1980), after the 6-year intervention (1985/1986), and 3 years later at follow-up (1989/1990). Net treatment/control differences in risk-factor change were assessed for women and men 25 to 74 years of age.
Blood pressure improvements observed in all cities from baseline to the end of the intervention were maintained during the follow-up in treatment but not control cities. Cholesterol levels continued to decline in all cities during follow-up. Smoking rates leveled out or increased slightly in treatment cities and continued to decline in control cities but did not yield significant net differences. Both coronary heart disease and all-cause mortality risk scores were maintained or continued to improve in treatment cities while leveling out or rebounding in control cities.
These findings suggest that community-based cardiovascular disease prevention trials can have sustained effects. However, the modest net differences in risk factors suggest the need for new designs and interventions that will accelerate positive risk-factor change.
本研究探讨了一项健康教育干预试验对降低心血管疾病风险的长期影响。
在加利福尼亚州的两个治疗城市和两个对照城市进行了调查,时间分别为基线期(1979/1980年)、6年干预期结束后(1985/1986年)以及3年后的随访期(1989/1990年)。评估了25至74岁男性和女性在危险因素变化方面的净治疗/对照差异。
从基线到干预结束时,所有城市观察到的血压改善在随访期间在治疗城市得以维持,但对照城市未维持。随访期间,所有城市的胆固醇水平持续下降。治疗城市的吸烟率趋于平稳或略有上升,对照城市的吸烟率继续下降,但未产生显著的净差异。治疗城市的冠心病和全因死亡率风险评分保持不变或继续改善,而对照城市则趋于平稳或反弹。
这些发现表明,基于社区的心血管疾病预防试验可能具有持续效果。然而,危险因素方面适度的净差异表明需要新的设计和干预措施,以加速危险因素的正向变化。