Breslin F C, Sobell S L, Sobell L C, Sobell M B
Addiction Research Foundation, Canada.
Addict Behav. 1997 Mar-Apr;22(2):145-55. doi: 10.1016/s0306-4603(95)00109-3.
This article reviews the 61 alcohol treatment outcome studies published from 1989-1993 with respect to methodology. Although better assessment of subjects' pretreatment characteristics was noted, a minority of studies met even the basic requirements of experimental studies. Further, some reversals of methodological progress were observed in several areas, particularly in collecting outcome data from multiple sources. It is suggested that funding agencies and journal editors require that submissions meet minimum standards for adequate outcome evaluation.
本文回顾了1989年至1993年发表的61项酒精治疗效果研究的方法学。尽管注意到对受试者治疗前特征的评估有所改善,但只有少数研究符合实验研究的基本要求。此外,在几个领域观察到方法学进展出现了一些倒退,特别是在从多个来源收集结果数据方面。建议资助机构和期刊编辑要求投稿符合充分结果评估的最低标准。