Beitchman J H, Young A R
Child and Family Studies Centre, Clarke Institute of Psychiatry, Toronto, Canada.
J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 1997 Aug;36(8):1020-32. doi: 10.1097/00004583-199708000-00009.
To review the past 10 years of clinical and research reports on learning disorders.
The most common and best-researched type of learning disorder is reading disability, which is the focus of this review. A selective review of the literature from Psychological Abstracts and Index Medicus from 1985 to the present was conducted. This review focused on conceptual and methodological issues, current assessment practices, epidemiology, correlates of brain function, biological factors, predictors of reading achievement, core deficits, comorbidity reading development and instructional approaches, treatment, and outcome.
Definitional issues, still unresolved, bedevil the field with the debate between those for and those against discrepancy definitions of reading disabilities. Nevertheless considerable progress has been made. Phonological processing problems are now considered the main core deficit responsible for reading disabilities. Correlates of brain function and possible genetic factors are noted. Comorbidity with externalizing and internalizing disorders is described, and some theories for the overlap are identified. Studies on the comorbidity with internalizing disorders are lacking. Good assessment practice and promising approaches to remediation are identified. Unless a concurrent disorder is present, the use of medication for the treatment of reading disabilities should be considered experimental. Favorable outcomes are dependent on initial severity and a supportive home and school environment.
Much progress has been made in our understanding of learning disabilities, especially in reading disabilities. Resolution of definitional and conceptual issues will greatly assist research into assessment, treatment, and long-term outcome of learning disabilities with and without concurrent psychiatric disorders. Further research into the nature, extent, and correlates of comorbid learning disabilities and their treatment is much needed.
回顾过去10年关于学习障碍的临床和研究报告。
学习障碍最常见且研究最多的类型是阅读障碍,这是本综述的重点。对1985年至今《心理学文摘》和《医学索引》中的文献进行了选择性回顾。本综述聚焦于概念和方法问题、当前评估实践、流行病学、脑功能相关性、生物学因素、阅读成就的预测因素、核心缺陷、共病、阅读发展和教学方法、治疗及结果。
定义问题仍未解决,支持和反对阅读障碍差异定义的双方争论困扰着该领域。然而已取得了相当大的进展。语音加工问题现在被认为是导致阅读障碍的主要核心缺陷。注意到了脑功能相关性和可能的遗传因素。描述了与外化和内化障碍的共病情况,并确定了一些重叠的理论。缺乏关于与内化障碍共病的研究。确定了良好的评估实践和有前景的补救方法。除非存在并发疾病,否则使用药物治疗阅读障碍应被视为试验性的。良好的结果取决于初始严重程度以及支持性的家庭和学校环境。
我们对学习障碍,尤其是阅读障碍的理解取得了很大进展。定义和概念问题的解决将极大地有助于对有或无并发精神疾病的学习障碍的评估、治疗和长期结果的研究。非常需要对共病学习障碍的性质、程度、相关性及其治疗进行进一步研究。