Vitelli L L, Crow R S, Shahar E, Hutchinson R G, Rautaharju P M, Folsom A R
Division of Epidemiology, School of Public Health, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis 55454, USA.
Am J Cardiol. 1998 Feb 15;81(4):453-9. doi: 10.1016/s0002-9149(97)00937-5.
It has been well documented that the prevalence of certain electrocardiographic (ECG) findings among individuals free of coronary heart disease (CHD) differs by race. However, it is not known whether these differences exist independently of CHD risk factors (e.g., hypertension). We examined the ECG tracings of 2,686 apparently healthy, middle-aged African-American and white men and women who participated in the Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities Study and were at low risk of CHD. Using the Minnesota Code, among men, 46% of African-Americans, but only 25% of whites, had a minor ECG finding (p < 0.001). In women, 32% of African-Americans and 23% of whites had a minor ECG finding (p < 0.01). Specifically, the age-adjusted prevalences of high-amplitude R wave, ST elevation, T-wave findings, and prolonged P-R interval were statistically significantly higher in African-Americans. As for continuous ECG measurements, the R wave in leads V5 and V6, the S wave in V1, the J-point amplitude in leads V2 and V5, the P-R interval, and the Cornell voltage (¿S V3¿ + R aVL) for left ventricular hypertrophy were all significantly greater in African-Americans than in whites. However, in both men and women, the heart rate corrected QT interval was shorter in African-Americans than in whites. All of these findings remained statistically significant after further adjustment for traditional CHD risk factors. These results suggest that racial differences in electrocardiograms may not be explained entirely by differences in established CHD risk factors, and because current diagnostic ECG criteria are largely based on data from middle-aged white men and women, race should be considered in the interpretation of ECG findings.
有充分的文献记载,无冠心病(CHD)个体中某些心电图(ECG)表现的患病率因种族而异。然而,尚不清楚这些差异是否独立于CHD危险因素(如高血压)存在。我们检查了2686名显然健康的中年非裔美国人和白人男性及女性的心电图记录,这些人参与了社区动脉粥样硬化风险研究,且患CHD的风险较低。使用明尼苏达编码,在男性中,46%的非裔美国人有轻微心电图表现,而白人中只有25%有(p<0.001)。在女性中,32%的非裔美国人有轻微心电图表现,23%的白人有(p<0.01)。具体而言,经年龄调整后,非裔美国人高振幅R波、ST段抬高、T波表现及P-R间期延长的患病率在统计学上显著更高。至于连续心电图测量,非裔美国人V5和V6导联的R波、V1导联的S波、V2和V5导联的J点振幅、P-R间期以及用于诊断左心室肥厚的康奈尔电压(S V3+R aVL)均显著高于白人。然而,在男性和女性中,非裔美国人的心率校正QT间期均短于白人。在进一步调整传统CHD危险因素后,所有这些发现仍具有统计学意义。这些结果表明,心电图的种族差异可能不能完全由既定CHD危险因素的差异来解释,而且由于当前的诊断心电图标准很大程度上基于中年白人男性和女性的数据,因此在解释心电图结果时应考虑种族因素。