Müller U, Klimke A, Jänner M, Gaebel W
Forschungsstelle für Psychiatrische Soziologie, Psychiatrische Klinik, Heinrich-Heine-Universität, Rheinische Kliniken Düsseldorf.
Nervenarzt. 1998 Jan;69(1):15-26. doi: 10.1007/s001150050234.
A total of 451 German psychiatric hospitals were asked in 1995 about their use of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT). As ECT nowadays is well accepted as a therapeutic tool, we wanted to compare our data with data collected in former inquiries in 1977 and 1985 and to acquire information from the new German States. Since 1977, the use of ECT has evidently increased. The psychiatric hospitals that often use ECT are for scattered throughout the whole country. ECT is mainly indicated for febrile catatonia/febrile stupor and depressive stupor, not for schizophrenia. ECT is applied especially when depressive patients are resistant or intolerant of psychopharmacotherapy. The preparation and application correspond to the standards. One focus in the present study was the attitudes of the managing directors towards ECT. Data were collected by open questionnaires. When these data were compared with data from a standardized inquiry of 1985, a similar trend was found regarding positive statements about ECT. Statements are emphasized even more when using open questionnaires. If there is a strong indication for ECT, the basic attitudes of the managing directors toward ECT are very positive. However, its application is in fact much more influenced by social factors than by indication because of negative attitudes by colleagues and nursing staff and political and stereotypic thinking of the general population.
1995年,总共451家德国精神病医院被问及电休克疗法(ECT)的使用情况。由于ECT如今已被广泛认可为一种治疗手段,我们希望将我们的数据与1977年和1985年之前调查收集的数据进行比较,并从新的德国各州获取信息。自1977年以来,ECT的使用明显增加。经常使用ECT的精神病医院分布在全国各地。ECT主要用于治疗发热性紧张症/发热性木僵和抑郁性木僵,而非精神分裂症。特别是当抑郁患者对心理药物治疗有抵抗或不耐受时会应用ECT。其准备和应用符合标准。本研究的一个重点是院长们对ECT的态度。数据通过开放式问卷收集。当将这些数据与1985年标准化调查的数据进行比较时,发现关于ECT的积极陈述有类似趋势。使用开放式问卷时,这些陈述会被更加强调。如果有强烈的ECT适应症,院长们对ECT的基本态度非常积极。然而,由于同事和护理人员的消极态度以及普通大众的政治和刻板思维,其应用实际上更多地受到社会因素而非适应症的影响。