Ryan J, Nash S, Lyndon J
Department of Accident and Emergency Medicine, Royal Sussex County Hospital, Brighton.
J Accid Emerg Med. 1998 Jul;15(4):237-43. doi: 10.1136/emj.15.4.237.
To benchmark current practice in the management of adult patients presenting with seizures to the accident and emergency (A&E) departments by performing a comparative interdepartmental audit. To assess the quality and degree of completeness of documentation in A&E records and to develop a proforma for the documentation of any case presenting with a seizure which would incorporate management guidelines for use by A&E doctors.
This was a retrospective, criterion based audit carried out in 12 A&E departments in the South Thames region. It involved 1200 adult patients who presented to A&E departments after a seizure. The degree of completeness of A&E records was assessed using criteria identified by A&E consultants and neurologists. Guidelines for use in the management of patients with seizures have been produced.
Important aspects of the history and examination were frequently unrecorded in patients' notes. The recording of vital signs was particularly poor. A diversity of practice was shown between the departments that were audited and the number of investigations performed in each department varied considerably. Hospital admissions for patients with first seizures varied widely between departments, ranging from between 34.6% to 91.7% of cases. Documentation of advice given to patients about driving was evident in just 0.9% of cases.
Wide interdepartmental variation exists in both the quality of information recorded in A&E records and in the management of patients. Deficiencies could be minimised and potential improvements in the quality of documentation might be achieved by the introduction of a structured proforma incorporating pre-defined management guidelines.
通过开展部门间比较审计,对成人癫痫发作患者在急诊部门的当前治疗情况进行基准评估。评估急诊记录文件的质量和完整程度,并制定一份癫痫发作病例的记录模板,该模板将纳入供急诊医生使用的治疗指南。
这是一项在泰晤士河南部地区12个急诊部门进行的基于标准的回顾性审计。涉及1200例癫痫发作后前往急诊部门就诊的成年患者。使用急诊顾问和神经科医生确定的标准评估急诊记录的完整程度。已制定癫痫患者治疗指南。
病史和检查的重要方面在患者病历中经常未被记录。生命体征的记录尤其差。接受审计的各部门之间存在多种治疗方式,且每个部门进行的检查数量差异很大。首次癫痫发作患者的住院率在各部门之间差异很大,范围从病例的34.6%至91.7%。仅0.9%的病例记录了给予患者关于驾驶的建议。
急诊记录中所记录信息的质量以及患者治疗情况在各部门之间存在很大差异。通过引入包含预定义治疗指南的结构化模板,可将缺陷降至最低,并可能提高文件记录的质量。