Sierra M, Berrios G E
Department of Psychiatry, University of Cambridge, United Kingdom.
Biol Psychiatry. 1998 Nov 1;44(9):898-908. doi: 10.1016/s0006-3223(98)00015-8.
Depersonalization remains a fascinating and obscure clinical phenomenon. In addition to earlier Jacksonian neurobiological adumbrations, and conventional psychodynamic accounts, views started to be expressed in the 1930s that depersonalization might be a vestigial form of behavior, and since the 1960s that it might be a phenomenon related to the temporal lobe. Recent advances in the neurobiology of the limbic system, and the application of Geschwind's concept of disconnection in the corticolimbic system, have opened the possibility of developing testable models. This paper includes a review of these ideas and of the clinical features of depersonalization, particularly of its emotional changes, suggesting that they are important for the neurobiological understanding of depersonalization. It also draws attention to clinical similarities between the experiential narratives produced by patients suffering from depersonalization and those with corticolimbic disconnections. On the basis of this, a new model is proposed according to which the state of increased alertness observed in depersonalization results from an activation of prefrontal attentional systems (right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex) and reciprocal inhibition of the anterior cingulate, leading to experiences of "mind emptiness" and "indifference to pain" often seen in depersonalization. On the other hand, a left-sided prefrontal mechanism would inhibit the amygdala resulting in dampened autonomic output, hypoemotionality, and lack of emotional coloring that would in turn, be reported as feelings of "unreality or detachment."
人格解体仍然是一种引人入胜但又晦涩难懂的临床现象。除了早期杰克逊式的神经生物学预示以及传统的精神动力学解释外,20世纪30年代开始有人认为人格解体可能是一种残留的行为形式,自20世纪60年代起又有人认为它可能是一种与颞叶相关的现象。边缘系统神经生物学的最新进展以及格施温德关于皮质边缘系统脱节概念的应用,为开发可测试模型开辟了可能性。本文回顾了这些观点以及人格解体的临床特征,特别是其情绪变化,表明这些对于从神经生物学角度理解人格解体很重要。它还提请注意人格解体患者所产生的体验性叙述与皮质边缘系统脱节患者叙述之间的临床相似性。在此基础上,提出了一种新模型,根据该模型,在人格解体中观察到的警觉性提高状态是由前额叶注意系统(右侧背外侧前额叶皮质)的激活以及前扣带回的相互抑制导致的,从而产生人格解体中常见的“思维空虚”和“对疼痛漠不关心”的体验。另一方面,左侧前额叶机制会抑制杏仁核,导致自主神经输出减弱、情绪低落以及缺乏情感色彩,进而表现为“不真实感或脱离感”。