Gyorkos T W, Tannenbaum T N, Abrahamowicz M, Delage G, Carsley J, Marchand S
Division of Clinical Epidemiology, Montreal General Hospital, Que.
CMAJ. 1998 Nov 3;159(9):1091-7.
The rationale for rubella vaccination in the general population and for screening for rubella in pregnant women is the prevention of congenital rubella syndrome. The objective of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of the prenatal rubella screening program in Quebec.
A historical cross-sectional study was designed. Sixteen hospitals with obstetric services were randomly selected, 8 from among the 35 "large" hospitals in the province (500 or more live births/year) and 8 from among the 50 "small" hospitals (fewer than 500 live births/year). A total of 2551 women were randomly selected from all mothers of infants born between Apr. 1, 1993, and Mar. 31, 1994, by means of stratified 2-stage sampling. The proportions of women screened and vaccinated were ascertained from information obtained from the hospital chart, the physician's office and the patient.
The overall (adjusted) screening rate was 94.0%. The rates were significantly different between large and small hospitals (94.4% v. 89.6%). Five large hospitals and one small hospital had rates above 95.0%. The likelihood of not having been screened was statistically significantly higher for women who had been pregnant previously than for women pregnant for the first time (4.8% v. 1.4%; p < 0.001). Of the 200 women who were seronegative at the time of screening (8.4%), 79 had been vaccinated postpartum, had a positive serological result on subsequent testing or did not require vaccination, and 59 had not been vaccinated postpartum; for 62, subsequent vaccination status was unknown.
Continued improvement in screening practices is needed, especially in small hospitals. Because vaccination rates are unacceptably low, it is crucial that steps be taken to address this issue.
在普通人群中接种风疹疫苗以及对孕妇进行风疹筛查的基本原理是预防先天性风疹综合征。本研究的目的是评估魁北克产前风疹筛查项目的有效性。
设计了一项历史性横断面研究。随机选择了16家提供产科服务的医院,其中8家来自该省35家“大型”医院(每年活产500例或更多),8家来自50家“小型”医院(每年活产少于500例)。通过分层两阶段抽样,从1993年4月1日至1994年3月31日期间出生的所有婴儿的母亲中随机选取了2551名妇女。从医院病历、医生办公室和患者那里获取的信息中确定接受筛查和接种疫苗的妇女比例。
总体(校正后)筛查率为94.0%。大型医院和小型医院的筛查率有显著差异(94.4%对89.6%)。5家大型医院和1家小型医院的筛查率高于95.0%。既往有过妊娠的妇女未接受筛查的可能性在统计学上显著高于首次怀孕的妇女(4.8%对1.4%;p<0.001)。在筛查时血清学阴性的200名妇女中(8.4%),79名妇女在产后接种了疫苗、后续检测血清学结果为阳性或不需要接种疫苗,59名妇女产后未接种疫苗;62名妇女的后续接种情况未知。
需要持续改进筛查措施,尤其是在小型医院。由于接种率低得令人无法接受,采取措施解决这一问题至关重要。