Gulløv A L, Koefoed B G, Petersen P
Department of Rheumatology, Glostrup University Hospital, Denmark.
Arch Intern Med. 1999 Jun 28;159(12):1322-8. doi: 10.1001/archinte.159.12.1322.
Treatment with warfarin sodium is effective for stroke prevention in atrial fibrillation but many physicians hesitate to prescribe it to elderly patients presumably because of the associated risk for bleeding and the inconvenience of frequent blood tests for the patients.
In the Second Copenhagen Atrial Fibrillation, Aspirin, and Anticoagulation (AFASAK 2) Study, we studied the rate of bleeding events associated with the incidence of thromboembolic events in patients receiving warfarin sodium, 1.25 mg/d; warfarin sodium, 1.25 mg/d, plus aspirin, 300 mg/d; aspirin, 300 mg/d; or adjusted-dose warfarin therapy aiming at an international normalized ratio of the prothrombin time ratio (INR) of 2.0 to 3.0. The study was scheduled for 6 years from May 1, 1993, but owing to evidence of inefficiency of low-intensity therapy plus aspirin from another study it was prematurely terminated on October 2, 1996. Minor and major bleeding events were recorded prospectively. The rate of bleeding was calculated using the Kaplan-Meier method and risk factors were identified by the Cox proportional hazards model.
Of 677 included patients, 130 (median age, 77 years; range, 67-89 years) experienced bleeding. One woman and 12 men experienced major bleeding. Four had intracranial bleeding: 2 cases were fatal and 2 were nonfatal. During treatment with mini-dose warfarin, warfarin plus aspirin, aspirin, and adjusted-dose warfarin, the annual rate of major bleeding was 0.8%, 0.3%, 1.4%, and 1.1%, respectively (P = .20). After 3 years of treatment the cumulative rate of any bleeding was 24.7%, 24.4%, 30.0%, and 41.1% (P = .003), respectively. Increasing INRvalue (P<.001) and prior myocardial infarction (P = .001) were independent risk factors for bleeding, whereas increasing age was not.
Fixed mini-dose warfarin and aspirin alone or in combination were associated with both minor and major bleeding. The small number of major bleeding events in patients receiving adjusted-dose warfarin therapy as compared with those receiving less intensive antithrombotic treatments and the finding of no significant influence of age on the risk for bleeding indicate that even elderly patients with atrial fibrillation tolerate adjusted-dose warfarin therapy (INR, 2.0-3.0).
华法林钠用于预防心房颤动患者发生中风有效,但许多医生不愿给老年患者开此药,可能是因为存在出血风险以及患者频繁进行血液检查带来不便。
在第二次哥本哈根心房颤动、阿司匹林及抗凝治疗(AFASAK 2)研究中,我们研究了接受1.25毫克/天华法林钠、1.25毫克/天华法林钠加300毫克/天阿司匹林、300毫克/天阿司匹林或目标国际标准化比值(INR)为2.0至3.0的调整剂量华法林治疗的患者中,出血事件发生率与血栓栓塞事件发生率的相关性。该研究计划从1993年5月1日起为期6年,但由于另一项研究显示低强度治疗加阿司匹林无效,于1996年10月2日提前终止。前瞻性记录轻微和严重出血事件。采用Kaplan-Meier方法计算出血率,并通过Cox比例风险模型确定危险因素。
677例纳入患者中,130例(中位年龄77岁;范围67 - 89岁)发生出血。1名女性和12名男性发生严重出血。4例发生颅内出血:2例致命,2例非致命。在小剂量华法林、华法林加阿司匹林、阿司匹林及调整剂量华法林治疗期间,严重出血的年发生率分别为0.8%、0.3%、1.4%和1.1%(P = 0.20)。治疗3年后,任何出血的累积发生率分别为24.7%、24.4%、30.0%和41.1%(P = 0.003)。INR值升高(P < 0.001)和既往心肌梗死(P = 0.001)是出血的独立危险因素,而年龄增加不是。
固定小剂量华法林和阿司匹林单独或联合使用均与轻微和严重出血相关。与接受强度较低的抗血栓治疗的患者相比,接受调整剂量华法林治疗的患者严重出血事件较少,且年龄对出血风险无显著影响,这表明即使是老年心房颤动患者也能耐受调整剂量的华法林治疗(INR为2.0 - 3.0)。