Wykes T, Reeder C, Corner J, Williams C, Everitt B
Department of Psychology, Institute of Psychiatry, London, UK.
Schizophr Bull. 1999;25(2):291-307. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.schbul.a033379.
Approaches to cognitive remediation have differed across studies. Most of the larger studies have concentrated on group treatments designed without the benefit of recent laboratory-based studies. The current study describes a randomized trial of an intensive cognitive remediation program involving individual daily sessions of 1 hour for up to 3 months. It targets executive functioning deficits (cognitive flexibility, working memory, and planning) that are known to be problematic in people with schizophrenia. Procedural learning, as well as the principles of errorless learning, targeted reinforcement, and massed practice, was the basis of the intervention. The program was compared with an alternative therapy (intensive occupational therapy) to control for some of the effects of therapeutic contact. Some improvements in cognition followed both therapies. A differential effect in favor of cognitive remediation therapy was found for tests in the cognitive flexibility and the memory subgroups. There was a trend for those receiving atypical antipsychotic medication to benefit more from cognitive remediation for tests of cognitive flexibility. Although there were no consistent changes in symptoms or social functioning between groups, if improvement in cognitive flexibility tasks reached a threshold then there is some evidence that social functioning improved, even over the short duration of the trial. In addition, cognitive remediation differentially improved self-esteem. This study supports the view that cognitive remediation can reduce cognitive deficits and that this reduction may affect social outcome, at least in the short term.
认知康复的方法在不同研究中存在差异。大多数规模较大的研究集中在未经近期基于实验室的研究所支持而设计的团体治疗上。本研究描述了一项强化认知康复计划的随机试验,该计划包括每天1小时的个体治疗,为期长达3个月。它针对执行功能缺陷(认知灵活性、工作记忆和计划),这些缺陷在精神分裂症患者中是已知的问题。程序学习以及无错误学习、针对性强化和集中练习的原则是干预的基础。该计划与另一种疗法(强化职业疗法)进行比较,以控制治疗接触的一些影响。两种疗法后认知都有一些改善。在认知灵活性和记忆亚组的测试中发现了有利于认知康复治疗的差异效应。接受非典型抗精神病药物治疗的患者在认知灵活性测试中从认知康复中获益更多,这存在一种趋势。尽管两组之间在症状或社会功能方面没有一致的变化,但如果认知灵活性任务的改善达到一个阈值,那么有一些证据表明社会功能得到了改善,即使在试验的短时间内也是如此。此外,认知康复对自尊有不同程度的改善。本研究支持这样一种观点,即认知康复可以减少认知缺陷,并且这种减少可能会影响社会结果,至少在短期内是这样。