Pirog E C, Chen Y T, Isacson C
Department of Pathology, New York Presbyterian Hospital-Weill Medical College of Cornell University, NY 10021, USA.
Am J Surg Pathol. 2000 Oct;24(10):1393-9. doi: 10.1097/00000478-200010000-00009.
The histopathologic diagnosis of vulvar condyloma acuminatum is often based on architectural features that are not specific for human papillomavirus (HPV) infection. Because HPV-associated lesions show increased cellular proliferation, the authors evaluated the usefulness of MIB-1 immunostaining as an aid in the differential diagnosis of cases equivocal for condyloma. The MIB-1 immunostaining pattern was correlated with HPV DNA detection in condyloma acuminatum (CON-A; n = 15), "consistent with condyloma" (c/w CON-A; n = 26), fibroepithelial polyp (FEP; n = 14), and squamous papilloma (n = 10). HPV was detected in 100% of the CON-A cases, and all cases demonstrated MIB-1-positive nuclei in the upper two thirds of the epithelial thickness. With this definition of MIB-1 positivity, there was complete concordance between MIB-1 positivity and HPV detection for all cases (kappa = 0.88). Of the cases c/w CON-A, 17 of 26 (65%) were positive for both MIB-1 and HPV, and could be reclassified as CON-A, whereas 35% were identified as an overdiagnosis based on negative results. In addition, two cases of FEP were MIB-1 and HPV positive, and thus were identified as an underdiagnosis. These results suggest significant overdiagnosis of cases equivocal for condyloma, and indicate that MIB-1 immunostaining is a beneficial adjunctive test when the morphologic features are suggestive but not diagnostic for CON-A.
外阴尖锐湿疣的组织病理学诊断通常基于并非人乳头瘤病毒(HPV)感染所特有的结构特征。由于HPV相关病变显示细胞增殖增加,作者评估了MIB-1免疫染色在尖锐湿疣疑似病例鉴别诊断中的作用。将MIB-1免疫染色模式与尖锐湿疣(CON-A;n = 15)、“符合尖锐湿疣”(c/w CON-A;n = 26)、纤维上皮息肉(FEP;n = 14)和鳞状乳头瘤(n = 10)中的HPV DNA检测结果进行关联分析。在100%的CON-A病例中检测到HPV,所有病例在上皮厚度的上三分之二区域均显示MIB-1阳性细胞核。根据MIB-1的这一定义,所有病例的MIB-1阳性与HPV检测结果完全一致(kappa = 0.88)。在c/w CON-A病例中,26例中有17例(65%)MIB-1和HPV均为阳性,可重新分类为CON-A,而35%的病例基于阴性结果被判定为过度诊断。此外,2例FEP病例MIB-1和HPV呈阳性,因此被判定为诊断不足。这些结果提示尖锐湿疣疑似病例存在显著的过度诊断情况,并表明当形态学特征提示但不能确诊CON-A时,MIB-1免疫染色是一项有益的辅助检查。