Johnson C D, Kingsnorth A N, Imrie C W, McMahon M J, Neoptolemos J P, McKay C, Toh S K, Skaife P, Leeder P C, Wilson P, Larvin M, Curtis L D
University Surgical Unit, F Level, Centre Block, Southampton General Hospital, Tremona Road, Southampton SO16 6YD, UK.
Gut. 2001 Jan;48(1):62-9. doi: 10.1136/gut.48.1.62.
Platelet activating factor (PAF) is believed to amplify the activity of key mediators of the systemic inflammatory response syndrome (SIRS) in acute pancreatitis, resulting in multiorgan dysfunction syndrome. We tested the hypothesis that a potent PAF antagonist, lexipafant, could dampen SIRS and reduce organ failure in severe acute pancreatitis.
We conducted a randomised, double blind, placebo controlled, multicentre trial of lexipafant (100 mg/24 hours intravenously for seven days commenced within 72 hours of the onset of symptoms) involving 290 patients with an APACHE II score >6. Power calculations assumed that complications would be reduced from 40% to 24%. Secondary end points studied included severity of organ failure, markers of the inflammatory response, and mortality rate.
Overall, 80/138 (58%) patients in the placebo group and 85/148 (57%) in the lexipafant group developed one or more organ failures. The primary hypothesis was invalidated by the unexpected finding that 44% of patients had organ failure on entry into the study; only 39 (14%) developed new organ failure. Organ failure scores were reduced in the lexipafant group only on day 3: median change -1 (range -4 to +8) versus 0 (-4 to +10) in the placebo group (p=0.04). Systemic sepsis affected fewer patients in the lexipafant group (13/138 v 4/148; p=0.023). Local complications occurred in 41/138 (30%) patients in the placebo group and in 30/148 (20%) in the lexipafant group (20%; p=0.065); pseudocysts developed in 19 (14%) and eight (5%) patients, respectively (p=0.025). Deaths attributable to acute pancreatitis were not significantly different. Interleukin 8, a marker of neutrophil activation, and E-selectin, a marker of endothelial damage, decreased more rapidly in the lexipafant group (both p<0.05); however, absolute values were not different between the two groups.
The high incidence of organ failure within 72 hours of the onset of symptoms undermined the primary hypothesis, and power calculations for future studies in severe acute pancreatitis will need to allow for this. Lexipafant had no effect on new organ failure during treatment. This adequately powered study has shown that antagonism of PAF activity on its own is not sufficient to ameliorate SIRS in severe acute pancreatitis
血小板活化因子(PAF)被认为可增强急性胰腺炎中全身炎症反应综合征(SIRS)关键介质的活性,从而导致多器官功能障碍综合征。我们检验了如下假设:强效PAF拮抗剂来昔帕泛可减轻严重急性胰腺炎中的SIRS并减少器官衰竭。
我们进行了一项来昔帕泛(症状发作72小时内开始静脉注射100mg/24小时,共7天)的随机、双盲、安慰剂对照、多中心试验,涉及290例急性生理与慢性健康状况评分系统II(APACHE II)评分>6的患者。功效计算假定并发症将从40%降至24%。研究的次要终点包括器官衰竭的严重程度、炎症反应标志物及死亡率。
总体而言,安慰剂组138例患者中有80例(58%)、来昔帕泛组148例患者中有85例(57%)发生了一种或多种器官衰竭。主要假设因一项意外发现而不成立:44%的患者在进入研究时已有器官衰竭;仅39例(14%)出现了新的器官衰竭。仅在第3天,来昔帕泛组的器官衰竭评分有所降低:中位数变化为-1(范围-4至+8),而安慰剂组为0(-4至+10)(p=0.04)。来昔帕泛组发生全身性脓毒症的患者较少(13/138比4/148;p=0.023)。安慰剂组138例患者中有41例(30%)发生局部并发症,来昔帕泛组148例患者中有30例(20%)发生局部并发症(p=0.065);分别有19例(14%)和8例(5%)患者形成假性囊肿(p=0.025)。急性胰腺炎所致死亡无显著差异。中性粒细胞活化标志物白细胞介素8和内皮损伤标志物E选择素在来昔帕泛组下降更快(均p<0.05);然而,两组的绝对值并无差异。
症状发作72小时内器官衰竭的高发生率削弱了主要假设,未来严重急性胰腺炎研究的功效计算需考虑这一点。来昔帕泛在治疗期间对新的器官衰竭无影响。这项有充分统计学效力的研究表明,单独拮抗PAF活性不足以改善严重急性胰腺炎中的SIRS