Ikem Abua, Odueyungbo Seyi, Egiebor Nosa O, Nyavor Kafui
Chemical Engineering Department, Tuskegee University, AL 36088, USA.
Sci Total Environ. 2002 Feb 21;285(1-3):165-75. doi: 10.1016/s0048-9697(01)00915-9.
Twenty-five brands of bottled waters consisting of both purified and spring types collected randomly from three Alabama cities, USA were assessed for their suitability for human consumption. Water quality constituents analyzed include pH, conductivity, alkalinity, chloride, nitrate + nitrite, sulfate, phosphate, total carbon (TC), inorganic carbon (IC), total organic carbon (TOC), and 27 elements on the inductively coupled plasma-optical emission spectrometer (ICP-OES). The results obtained were compared with US EPA drinking water standards and the European union (EU) drinking water directive. Ni was non-detectable in all the samples and Cu, Pb, Sb, Zn, Mn, Al, Cr, Mg, P, Ca, sulfate, chloride and nitrates + nitrites were all below their respective USEPA drinking water standards or EU maximum admissible concentrations (MAC). The conductivity, pH, As, Cd, Hg, Zn, Se and Tl values in some samples exceeded the EU and USEPA standards for drinking water. No sample had pH > 8.5, but seven bottled water brands analyzed were acidic (pH < 6.5). Most of the sampled brands had TOC concentrations exceeding 3 mg/l. The concentrations of most water quality constituents analyzed, in most cases, were higher in the spring water brands compared to the purified or distilled brands of bottled water. A one-way parametric analysis of variance (ANOVA) conducted on pH, conductivity, IC, TOC, Ca, Na, K, Mg, Se, sulfate, chloride and nitrate + nitrite values for 10 brands of bottled water to ascertain the homogeneity of variances within and between the brands, suggested significant differences in variances across the brands at a 95% confidence level except for selenium, sodium and calcium.
从美国阿拉巴马州三个城市随机收集了25个品牌的瓶装水,包括纯净水和泉水,对其是否适合人类饮用进行了评估。分析的水质成分包括pH值、电导率、碱度、氯化物、硝酸盐+亚硝酸盐、硫酸盐、磷酸盐、总碳(TC)、无机碳(IC)、总有机碳(TOC),以及通过电感耦合等离子体发射光谱仪(ICP-OES)测定的27种元素。将所得结果与美国环境保护局(US EPA)的饮用水标准和欧盟(EU)的饮用水指令进行了比较。所有样品中均未检测到镍,铜、铅、锑、锌、锰、铝、铬、镁、磷、钙、硫酸盐、氯化物和硝酸盐+亚硝酸盐均低于各自的美国环境保护局饮用水标准或欧盟最大允许浓度(MAC)。一些样品中的电导率、pH值、砷、镉、汞、锌、硒和铊的值超过了欧盟和美国环境保护局的饮用水标准。没有样品的pH值>8.5,但分析的7个瓶装水品牌呈酸性(pH<6.5)。大多数抽样品牌的总有机碳浓度超过3mg/L。在大多数情况下,与纯净水或蒸馏水品牌的瓶装水相比,泉水品牌中分析的大多数水质成分浓度更高。对10个品牌瓶装水的pH值、电导率、无机碳、总有机碳、钙、钠、钾、镁、硒、硫酸盐、氯化物和硝酸盐+亚硝酸盐值进行了单因素参数方差分析(ANOVA),以确定各品牌内部和之间方差的同质性,结果表明,除硒、钠和钙外,在95%置信水平下各品牌之间的方差存在显著差异。