Hay Alastair D, Wilson Andrew D
Department of General Practice and Primary Health Care, University of Leicester.
Br J Gen Pract. 2002 May;52(478):401-9.
Professional and parental uncertainty regarding the natural history of cough and respiratory tract infection (R77) in pre-school children may in part be responsible for the high consultation, reconsultation, and antibiotic prescribing rates in this age group. The aim of the study was to review the evidence about the natural history of acute cough in children aged between 0 and 4 years presenting to primary care in terms of illness duration and complications. The study was a systematic review, with qualitative and quantitative data synthesis, of control and placebo arms of systematic reviews, randomised controlled trials (RCTs), and cohort studies set in primary care. Searches were done of MEDLINE (between 1966 and June 1998), EMBASE (between 1988 and September 1998), and the Cochrane Library databases, using the MeSH terms 'respiratory tract infection, 'cough, and 'bronchitis, and the textwords 'cough' 'bronchitis, and 'chest infection, limited to children aged between 0 and 4years, and English language articles. Eight RCTs and two cohort studies met the review criteria. At one week, 75% of children may have improved but 50% may be still coughing and/or have a nasal discharge. At two weeks up to 24% of children may be no better. Within two weeks of presentation, 12% of children may experience one or more complication, such as rash, painful ears, diarrhoea, vomiting, or progression to bronchitis/pneumonia. This review offers parents and clinicians more prognostic information about acute cough in pre-school children. Illness duration may be longer and complications higher than many parents and clinicians expect. This may help to set more realistic expectations of the illness and help parents to decide when and if to reconsult. This information may be useful to those designing patient information and self-help resources.
专业人士和家长对于学龄前儿童咳嗽及呼吸道感染(R77)自然病程的不确定,可能在一定程度上导致了该年龄组较高的就诊率、复诊率和抗生素处方率。本研究的目的是就0至4岁儿童在基层医疗就诊时急性咳嗽的自然病程,从病程和并发症方面回顾相关证据。本研究是一项系统评价,对基层医疗中的系统评价、随机对照试验(RCT)和队列研究的对照组及安慰剂组进行定性和定量数据综合分析。检索了MEDLINE(1966年至1998年6月)、EMBASE(1988年至1998年9月)和Cochrane图书馆数据库,使用医学主题词“呼吸道感染”“咳嗽”和“支气管炎”,以及文本词“咳嗽”“支气管炎”和“胸部感染”,限定为0至4岁儿童及英文文章。八项RCT和两项队列研究符合评价标准。在一周时,75%的儿童可能有所改善,但50%的儿童可能仍在咳嗽和/或有流涕症状。在两周时,高达至24%的儿童可能并无好转。在就诊两周内,1十二%的儿童可能会出现一种或多种并发症,如皮疹、耳痛、腹泻、呕吐,或发展为支气管炎/肺炎。本评价为家长和临床医生提供了更多关于学龄前儿童急性咳嗽的预后信息。病程可能比许多家长和临床医生预期的更长,并发症也更多。这可能有助于对该疾病设定更现实的期望,并帮助家长决定何时以及是否复诊。这些信息可能对设计患者信息和自助资源的人员有用。