Mann Samantha, Vrij Aldert, Bull Ray
Department of Psychology, University of Portsmouth, Hants, United Kingdom.
Law Hum Behav. 2002 Jun;26(3):365-76. doi: 10.1023/a:1015332606792.
This study is one of the very few, and the most extensive to date, which has examined deceptive behavior in a real-life, high-stakes setting. The behavior of 16 suspects in their police interviews has been analyzed. Clips of video footage have been selected where other sources (reliable witness statements and forensic evidence) provide evidence that the suspect lied or told the truth. Truthful and deceptive behaviors were compared. The suspects blinked less frequently and made longer pauses during deceptive clips than during truthful clips. Eye contact was maintained equally for deceptive and truthful clips. These findings negate the popular belief amongst both laypersons and professional lie detectors (such as the police) that liars behave nervously by fidgeting and avoiding eye contact. However, large individual differences were present.
这项研究是为数不多的、也是迄今为止最全面的研究之一,它考察了现实生活中高风险场景下的欺骗行为。分析了16名嫌疑人在警方讯问中的行为。选取了视频片段,其中其他来源(可靠证人陈述和法医证据)提供了嫌疑人说谎或讲真话的证据。对真实行为和欺骗行为进行了比较。与真实片段相比,嫌疑人在欺骗片段中眨眼频率更低,停顿时间更长。欺骗片段和真实片段中的眼神接触保持程度相同。这些发现否定了外行人和专业测谎者(如警方)中普遍存在的一种观念,即说谎者会通过坐立不安和避免眼神接触来表现得紧张。然而,个体差异很大。