What is the cardioprotective role of hormone replacement therapy?

A very large body of literature has yielded strong biologic and mechanistic plausibility for the consistent observational findings that estrogen is cardioprotective. Recently completed randomized, controlled trials have been interpreted as challenging the doctrine that hormone replacement is cardioprotective for postmenopausal women. However, other than the Estrogen in the Prevention of Atherosclerosis Trial, none of the currently completed (and no ongoing) randomized, controlled trials have appropriately tested the hypothesis generated from observational data that estrogen replacement is cardioprotective. This mainly results from the fact that randomized, controlled trials have not tested the same pattern and type of hormone use in the same population of women observed in the epidemiologic studies. On the other hand, recently completed randomized, controlled trials provide important but limited information concerning the clinical use of a specific regimen of hormone replacement for the prevention of cardiovascular disease in a particular population of postmenopausal women. Observations made from epidemiologic studies will have to be appropriately tested in randomized, controlled trials before any real conclusions can be drawn as to whether hormone replacement is cardioprotective.