Picciano Anne, Winter Robin, Ballan Douglas, Birnberg Bruce, Jacks Maryann, Laing Euton
JFK Family Practice Residency Program, UMDNJ-Robert Wood Johnson Medical School, Edison, NJ 08818, USA.
Fam Med. 2003 Jun;35(6):418-22.
Noontime conferences are widely used in family practice residencies. This study determined the effectiveness of noontime conferences for increasing residents' knowledge.
Twenty residents were tested monthly over 6 months and then cumulatively on the content of noontime conferences.
Monthly test scores of attendees versus nonattendees were compared using a two-sample, two-tail t test. Results revealed the mean score of attendees for short-term knowledge to be 12.1 points higher than nonattendees. There was no correlation, however, between conference attendance and long-term knowledge retention.
Our findings indicate a lack of correlation between noontime conference attendance and long-term cumulative test scores. The results question the value of noontime conferences as a teaching method.
午餐时间会议在家庭医学住院医师培训项目中被广泛使用。本研究确定了午餐时间会议在增加住院医师知识方面的有效性。
20名住院医师在6个月内每月接受测试,然后对午餐时间会议的内容进行累积测试。
使用双样本双侧t检验比较了参会者与未参会者的月度测试成绩。结果显示,参会者短期知识的平均成绩比未参会者高12.1分。然而,会议出席情况与长期知识保留之间没有相关性。
我们的研究结果表明,午餐时间会议出席情况与长期累积测试成绩之间缺乏相关性。这些结果质疑了午餐时间会议作为一种教学方法的价值。