Yassa R, Jeste D V
Douglas Hospital, Verdun, Quebec, Canada.
Schizophr Bull. 1992;18(4):701-15. doi: 10.1093/schbul/18.4.701.
We analyzed data from 76 selected studies on prevalence of tardive dyskinesia (TD), published through 1989. The primary focus was on gender differences. The overall prevalence of TD in the 39,187 patients included in these reports was 24.2 percent, and prevalence was significantly higher in women (26.6%) than in men (21.6%). The gender difference in TD prevalence appeared to narrow intriguingly in more recent studies. Overall, the TD prevalence seemed to reach its peak in the 50-70-year-old age group in men and continued to rise after age 70 in women. Also, women tended to have more severe TD than men. Spontaneous dyskinesia too was found to be more common in women. The material was also analyzed for cultural differences by comparing studies in four continents: North America, Europe, Africa, and Asia. Although grouping together studies from different countries in a continent into a single group is somewhat problematic, we found that Asian patients had lower prevalence of TD than North American, European, and African patients. Limitations of our review (including differences among studies in diagnostic criteria, observer bias, etc.) as well as possible explanations for the reported differences in the risk for TD are discussed.
我们分析了截至1989年发表的76项关于迟发性运动障碍(TD)患病率的精选研究数据。主要关注点是性别差异。这些报告中纳入的39187名患者的TD总体患病率为24.2%,女性患病率(26.6%)显著高于男性(21.6%)。在最近的研究中,TD患病率的性别差异似乎有趣地缩小了。总体而言,男性TD患病率似乎在50 - 70岁年龄组达到峰值,而女性在70岁以后患病率继续上升。此外,女性的TD往往比男性更严重。还发现自发性运动障碍在女性中更常见。通过比较四大洲(北美、欧洲、非洲和亚洲)的研究,对材料进行了文化差异分析。尽管将一个大陆不同国家的研究归为一组存在一定问题,但我们发现亚洲患者的TD患病率低于北美、欧洲和非洲患者。讨论了我们综述的局限性(包括研究在诊断标准、观察者偏差等方面的差异)以及所报告的TD风险差异的可能解释。