Carr Mitchell, Jones Jeffery
Galvin Center for Health and Fitness, Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago, Illinois, USA.
Top Stroke Rehabil. 2003 Winter;9(4):57-64. doi: 10.1310/0J2K-MDNX-1Q0L-8LX6.
This study investigated the physiological responses of stroke survivors to a 16-week program of moderate aerobic and anaerobic exercise.
Forty participants who were a minimum of 6 months post stroke underwent physiological testing over the course of 2 days that included a maximal VO(2) stress test, a Biodex strength assessment, and a blood lipid panel. The participants were then randomly assigned to two groups, an aerobic training only (ATO) group and an aerobic and strength training (A&ST) group. Both groups were then required to exercise aerobically for 20 minutes for 3 days a week at a moderate intensity for 16 weeks. Only the A&ST group was required to do a series of eight strength-training activities as part of their exercise protocol. Once the 16-week protocol was completed, all tests were repeated. These results were compared to the pretest data.
Statistically significant changes in VO(2max) were noted in the A&ST group, while positive but not significant changes were noted in the ATO group. Both groups saw significant increases in knee flexion but not in knee extension. The A&ST group showed significant increases in both shoulder flexion and extension, while the ATO group only had significant increases in shoulder extension.
We concluded that aerobic exercise produced positive metabolic changes in both groups, but only the A&ST group had statistically significant changes. Both groups demonstrated significant changes in functional strength, but the A&ST group experienced larger increases, likely due to the strength component of their training protocol.
本研究调查了中风幸存者对为期16周的适度有氧和无氧运动计划的生理反应。
40名中风后至少6个月的参与者在2天内接受了生理测试,包括最大摄氧量应激测试、Biodex力量评估和血脂检测。然后将参与者随机分为两组,即仅有氧训练(ATO)组和有氧与力量训练(A&ST)组。两组均被要求每周进行3天、每次20分钟的中等强度有氧运动,持续16周。只有A&ST组被要求进行一系列八项力量训练活动作为其运动方案的一部分。16周的方案完成后,重复所有测试。将这些结果与测试前的数据进行比较。
A&ST组的最大摄氧量有统计学意义的变化,而ATO组有积极但无统计学意义的变化。两组的膝关节屈曲均显著增加,但膝关节伸展未增加。A&ST组的肩关节屈曲和伸展均显著增加,而ATO组仅肩关节伸展有显著增加。
我们得出结论,有氧运动在两组中都产生了积极的代谢变化,但只有A&ST组有统计学意义的变化。两组在功能力量方面均有显著变化,但A&ST组的增加幅度更大,可能是由于其训练方案中的力量部分。