Ravaldi Claudia, Vannacci Alfredo, Zucchi Teresa, Mannucci Edoardo, Cabras Pier Luigi, Boldrini Maura, Murciano Loriana, Rotella Carlo Maria, Ricca Valdo
Psychiatry Unit, Department of Neurology and Psychiatry, Florence University Medical School, Florence, Italy.
Psychopathology. 2003 Sep-Oct;36(5):247-54. doi: 10.1159/000073450.
Eating disorders are frequent among elite performers of certain sports or physical activities; however, little is known about non-professional performers.
113 female non-elite ballet dancers, 54 female gymnasium users, 44 male non-competitive body builders, 105 female controls and 30 male controls were evaluated using the Body Uneasiness Test, the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory, the Beck Depression Inventory, and the Eating Disorder Examination 12th edition (EDE-12).
Non-elite ballet dancers reported the highest prevalence of eating disorders (anorexia nervosa 1.8%; bulimia nervosa 2.7%; eating disorders not otherwise specified 22.1%), followed by gymnasium users (anorexia nervosa 2.6%; eating disorders not otherwise specified 18%). Significant differences (p < 0.01) between athletes and their controls were found in the following parameters (median values): Beck Depression Inventory (female dancers 5.7, gymnasium users 6.1, female controls 2.8, body builders 1.6, and male controls 1.3), Body Uneasiness Test (female dancers 1.08, gymnasium users 0.62, female controls 0.54, body builders 0.35, and male controls 0.27), EDE total scores (female dancers 1.6, gymnasium users 1.7, female controls 1.0, body builders 1.0, and male controls 0.4), EDE - restraint subscale scores (female dancers 0.8, gymnasium users 1.6, female controls 0.0, body builders 0.8, and male controls 0.0), EDE--eating concern subscale scores (female dancers 0.4, gymnasium users 0.2, female controls 0.0, body builders 0.0, and male controls 0.0), EDE--weight concern subscale scores (female dancers 2.1, gymnasium users 2.1, female controls 1.6, body builders 1.4, and male controls 0.5), and EDE--shape concern subscale scores (female dancers 2.7, gymnasium users 2.8, female controls 2.0, body builders 2.1, and male controls 0.9). EDE scores were highly related to Body Uneasiness Test scores, especially in non-elite ballet dancers and in non-competitive body builders (p < 0.01).
Non-professional performers of sports emphasising thinness or muscularity, such as ballet and body-building, show a high degree of body uneasiness and inappropriate eating attitudes and behaviours.
饮食失调在某些体育或身体活动的精英从业者中很常见;然而,对于非专业从业者却知之甚少。
使用身体不适测试、状态-特质焦虑量表、贝克抑郁量表和第12版饮食失调检查量表(EDE-12)对113名非精英女性芭蕾舞演员、54名女性健身房使用者、44名非竞技男性健美运动员、105名女性对照者和30名男性对照者进行评估。
非精英芭蕾舞演员报告的饮食失调患病率最高(神经性厌食症1.8%;神经性贪食症2.7%;未另行规定的饮食失调22.1%),其次是健身房使用者(神经性厌食症2.6%;未另行规定的饮食失调18%)。在以下参数(中位数)中发现运动员与其对照者之间存在显著差异(p<0.01):贝克抑郁量表(女性舞者5.7,健身房使用者6.1,女性对照者2.8,健美运动员1.6,男性对照者1.3)、身体不适测试(女性舞者1.08,健身房使用者0.62,女性对照者0.54,健美运动员0.35,男性对照者0.27)、EDE总分(女性舞者1.6,健身房使用者1.7,女性对照者1.0,健美运动员1.0,男性对照者0.4)、EDE-克制分量表得分(女性舞者0.8,健身房使用者1.6,女性对照者0.0,健美运动员0.8,男性对照者0.0)、EDE-饮食关注分量表得分(女性舞者0.4,健身房使用者0.2,女性对照者0.0,健美运动员0.0,男性对照者0.0)、EDE-体重关注分量表得分(女性舞者2.1,健身房使用者2.1,女性对照者1.6,健美运动员1.4,男性对照者0.5)和EDE-体型关注分量表得分(女性舞者2.7,健身房使用者2.8,女性对照者2.0,健美运动员2.1,男性对照者0.9)。EDE得分与身体不适测试得分高度相关,尤其是在非精英芭蕾舞演员和非竞技健美运动员中(p<0.01)。
强调瘦或肌肉发达的体育项目的非专业从业者,如芭蕾舞和健美运动,表现出高度身体不适以及不适当的饮食态度和行为。