Berg John E.
Clinic of Psychiatry, Akershus University Hospital, Psychiatric Hospital Lurud, Skedsmokorset and the Institute of General Practice and Community Medicine, Section for Preventive Medicine and Epidemiology, University of Oslo, Norway.
Prim Care Companion J Clin Psychiatry. 2003 Aug;5(4):164-167. doi: 10.4088/pcc.v05n0404.
The outcome of therapeutic community treatment for drug abuse has been disputed with regard to mortality and rehabilitation to school or work as compared with other treatment modalities. METHOD: All patients (N = 130) admitted to a therapeutic community during 3 consecutive years (1996-1998), who had failed to stop abusing drugs after ambulatory and primary care initiatives, were assessed 1 to 4 years (mean = 36.5 months) after end of treatment. Rates of rehabilitation to school or work, changes in drug use patterns, and mortality were observed. RESULTS: Nine persons died during the observation period (the observation time to death seemed to be shorter in women than in men). The mortality rate per 100 observation years was 2.28. Among the surviving drug abusers, 39% were working or attending school at study endpoint. One fourth currently used drugs, and approximately 14% were enrolled in a methadone maintenance program. Another 13% were in treatment or prison. CONCLUSION: Drug abuse is an activity that increases the mortality rate, but among the surviving persons, a considerable number are rehabilitated, as assessed after a longer observation period. The authors suggest that this outcome could not have been attained with ambulatory general practice-driven services, even with empathic follow-up.
与其他治疗方式相比,戒毒治疗社区在药物滥用治疗方面的死亡率以及恢复上学或工作情况一直存在争议。方法:连续三年(1996 - 1998年)收治于戒毒治疗社区的所有患者(N = 130),这些患者在接受门诊及初级护理干预后仍未能停止滥用药物,在治疗结束后1至4年(平均36.5个月)进行评估。观察恢复上学或工作的比例、药物使用模式的变化以及死亡率。结果:观察期内有9人死亡(女性的观察至死亡时间似乎比男性短)。每100观察年的死亡率为2.28。在存活的药物滥用者中,39%在研究终点时正在工作或上学。四分之一的人目前仍在使用药物,约14%的人参加了美沙酮维持治疗项目。另有13%的人正在接受治疗或在监狱服刑。结论:药物滥用会增加死亡率,但在存活者中,经过较长观察期评估,相当一部分人实现了康复。作者认为,即使有富有同情心的随访,通过以门诊全科医疗为主导的服务也无法取得这样的结果。