Verwey Willem B, Clegg Benjamin A
Faculty of Behavioral Sciences, University of Twente, PO Box 217, 7500 AE, Enschede, The Netherlands.
Psychol Res. 2005 Mar;69(4):242-51. doi: 10.1007/s00426-004-0181-x. Epub 2004 Jul 3.
At least five earlier studies could not find effector-dependent learning in the keying version of the serial reaction time (RT) task. Experiment 1 examined whether effector-dependent learning occurs when participants practice the serial RT task with three fingers of one hand for about 1,300 sequence repetitions instead of the more common 50-100 repetitions. The results confirm that, following extended practice, sequence learning produces an effector-dependent component. Specifically, an unpracticed hand executed a practiced sequence slower than a practiced hand. However, Experiment 2 showed that effector-dependent sequence learning develops only when fingers of one hand are used, suggesting that effector-dependent sequence learning involves adjustment to the mechanical interactions between the fingers of one hand. In addition, when sequences had been practiced with one hand, mirror versions of the practiced sequences in both experiments showed moderate transfer. But when practiced with two hands no transfer to a mirrored version of the sequence was observed. This suggests that only practice with one hand produces a representation that facilitates the execution of mirror sequences. Generally, the same results were found in more or less aware participants, congruent with the idea that the effector-dependent representation and the representation allowing transfer to mirror sequences are implicit.
至少有五项早期研究在序列反应时(RT)任务的按键版本中未发现效应器依赖学习。实验1检验了在参与者用一只手的三根手指练习序列RT任务约1300次序列重复而非更常见的50 - 100次重复时,效应器依赖学习是否会发生。结果证实,经过长时间练习后,序列学习会产生一个效应器依赖成分。具体而言,未练习的手执行已练习序列的速度比已练习的手慢。然而,实验2表明,只有当使用一只手的手指时,效应器依赖序列学习才会发展,这表明效应器依赖序列学习涉及对一只手手指间机械相互作用的调整。此外,当用一只手练习序列时,在两个实验中,已练习序列的镜像版本都显示出适度的迁移。但当用两只手练习时,未观察到向序列镜像版本的迁移。这表明只有用一只手练习才能产生一种有助于执行镜像序列的表征。一般来说,在或多或少有意识的参与者中都发现了相同的结果,这与效应器依赖表征和允许向镜像序列迁移的表征是内隐的这一观点一致。