Gottlieb N H, Loukas A, Corrao M, McAlister A, Snell C, Huang P P
Department of Kinesiology & Health Education, The University of Texas at Austin, Bellmont Hall 222, Austin, TX 78712, USA.
Tob Control. 2004 Sep;13(3):237-43. doi: 10.1136/tc.2003.003988.
To test: (1) whether citation under the Minors in Possession (MIP) law, vicarious citation (knowing someone who was cited), and threat of driving licence suspension are associated with decreased intentions to smoke next year; and (2) whether the policy is differentially enforced.
28,249 white, Hispanic, and African American students in grades 6-12 (11-18 years old) participated in the study.
The 86 item anonymous Texas Youth Tobacco Survey was completed by students attending 37 schools in 14 east and central Texas communities.
Hierarchical linear modelling showed that MIP citation was unrelated to the future smoking intentions of most youth. However, there was a negative association between citation and smoking intentions for ever daily smoking youth at four schools. Threat of licence suspension was associated with a lower likelihood of future smoking intentions among ever daily smoking youth and vicarious citation did not deter youth from future smoking. African American and Hispanic youth had a higher probability of being cited than their peers.
Threat of driving licence suspension has the intended effect upon youth who are/were committed smokers and MIP citation has the intended effect upon committed smokers at only four schools. However, differential enforcement of the law based on ethnicity may be occurring. Before drawing firm conclusions, current findings must be replicated with longitudinal data to determine the consequences of citation on subsequent tobacco use.
检验:(1)持有未成年人烟草(MIP)法律下的传票、间接传票(认识被传票的人)以及驾照吊销威胁是否与明年吸烟意愿降低相关;以及(2)该政策的执行是否存在差异。
28249名6至12年级(11至18岁)的白人、西班牙裔和非裔美国学生参与了该研究。
来自德克萨斯州东部和中部14个社区37所学校的学生完成了86项匿名的德克萨斯青少年烟草调查。
分层线性模型显示,MIP传票与大多数青少年未来的吸烟意愿无关。然而,在四所学校中,传票与曾经每日吸烟的青少年的吸烟意愿之间存在负相关。驾照吊销威胁与曾经每日吸烟的青少年未来吸烟意愿较低的可能性相关,而间接传票并未阻止青少年未来吸烟。非裔美国人和西班牙裔青少年被传票的可能性高于同龄人。
驾照吊销威胁对曾经吸烟的青少年有预期效果,MIP传票仅在四所学校对曾经吸烟的青少年有预期效果。然而,基于种族的法律执行差异可能正在发生。在得出确凿结论之前,必须用纵向数据复制当前研究结果,以确定传票对后续烟草使用的影响。