Bower James H, Zenebe Guta
Department of Neurology, Mayo Clinic College of Medicine, 200 First Street SW, Rochester, MN 55905, USA.
Neurology. 2005 Feb 8;64(3):412-5. doi: 10.1212/01.WNL.0000150894.53961.E2.
To define the current state of neurologic health care services in the nations of Africa.
A survey on neurologic services was prepared in English, French, and Portuguese and sent to representatives of 53 of 53 African nations. Representatives for each country were identified first through the Pan African Association of Neurologic Sciences, followed by the World Federation of Neurology and the World Health Organization (WHO). If these representatives did not return survey results, contacts were attempted through officials in the embassies in Washington, DC, or Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, or local ministries of health.
Surveys were received from representatives of 38 (71.7%) of the 53 African nations. Data from the WHO were added for 12 nations, resulting in information on 50 (94.3%) of the 53 nations. The nations were divided into four categories according to the number of neurologists per nation. Group A (>10 neurologists/country) included 11 nations, averaging 711,856 population per neurologist. Group B (5 to 10 neurologists/country) included five nations, averaging 1,612,039 population per neurologist. Group C (1 to 4 neurologists/country) included 23 nations, averaging 5,099,908 population per neurologist. Group D included 12 nations with a total population of 25,939,273 that reported having no neurologists. The level of training, presence of local training programs, ancillary equipment, and practice setting options decreased progressively from Group A to Group D.
The population/neurologist ratio in all African nations far exceeds that of the United States and other developed nations. Neurologic services in the African nations range from no formal care at all to established neurologic care with residency training and ancillary equipment.
明确非洲各国神经保健服务的现状。
准备了一份英文、法文和葡萄牙文的神经科服务调查问卷,并发送给53个非洲国家中的53个国家的代表。每个国家的代表首先通过泛非洲神经科学协会确定,其次是世界神经病学联合会和世界卫生组织(WHO)。如果这些代表没有返回调查结果,则尝试通过驻华盛顿特区或埃塞俄比亚亚的斯亚贝巴大使馆的官员或当地卫生部进行联系。
收到了53个非洲国家中38个(71.7%)国家代表的调查问卷。又补充了来自世界卫生组织的12个国家的数据,从而得到了53个国家中50个(94.3%)国家的信息。根据每个国家神经科医生的数量,这些国家被分为四类。A组(每个国家>10名神经科医生)包括11个国家,平均每名神经科医生服务711,856人。B组(每个国家5至10名神经科医生)包括5个国家,平均每名神经科医生服务1,612,039人。C组(每个国家1至4名神经科医生)包括23个国家,平均每名神经科医生服务5,099,908人。D组包括12个国家,总人口为25,939,273,报告称没有神经科医生。从A组到D组,培训水平、当地培训项目的存在、辅助设备和执业环境选择逐渐下降。
所有非洲国家的人口与神经科医生的比例远远超过美国和其他发达国家。非洲国家的神经保健服务从完全没有正规护理到拥有住院医师培训和辅助设备的成熟神经保健服务不等。