Hildingsson Ingegerd, Rådestad Ingela, Waldenström Ulla
Department of Nursing, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden.
Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand. 2005 Mar;84(3):248-54. doi: 10.1111/j.0001-6349.2005.00615.x.
The national recommendation in Sweden regarding number of antenatal care visits was reduced in 1996. The aim of this study was to explore the factors associated with number of visits made and with women's own opinions about these visits. Another aim was to study associations between the number of visits and satisfaction with antenatal care overall.
All Swedish-speaking women who came for their first visit to the midwife in 593 participating clinics during 3 weeks evenly spread over 1 year in 1999-2000 were invited to participate in the study. Information was collected by postal questionnaires after the booking visit and 2 months after childbirth. Cases of preterm delivery and intrauterine death were excluded.
After excluding miscarriages, non-Swedish-speaking women, and women booked at non-participating clinics, about 69% of all women booked in antenatal care were recruited. Of these, 2421 (83%) completed the two questionnaires. About 25% followed the standard visiting schedule for a normal pregnancy, 57% made more visits, and 17% fewer visits. The number of visits made was associated with parity, medical diagnosis, depressive symptoms, level of education, and women's preferences in early pregnancy. Women's own opinion that they made too few visits was associated with a preference for more visits in early pregnancy and actually receiving fewer visits than the standard schedule. The view that they made too many visits was associated with a previous negative birth experience, a wish for fewer visits, having a medical diagnosis, many children, and major worries. The vast majority of women (87.6%) were satisfied with antenatal care overall but less with emotional (76.9%) than with medical (82.3%) aspects. No association was found between number of visits made and satisfaction, but women's own opinion that they had too few visits was associated with dissatisfaction with medical as well as emotional aspects of care and the opinion that they made too many visits with the emotional aspects of care.
Two-thirds of the women did not follow the standard visiting schedule, the majority of women made more visits. The number of antenatal visits seemed to be fairly well adapted to women's individual needs and, to some extent, to their own wishes. Very few women were dissatisfied with the number of visits made as well as the antenatal care overall.
瑞典1996年降低了关于产前检查次数的国家建议。本研究的目的是探讨与就诊次数以及女性对这些就诊的自身看法相关的因素。另一个目的是研究就诊次数与总体产前检查满意度之间的关联。
邀请了1999 - 2000年期间在593家参与诊所首次就诊于助产士的所有说瑞典语的女性参与研究,这3周均匀分布在1年中。在预约就诊后及分娩后2个月通过邮寄问卷收集信息。排除早产和宫内死亡病例。
排除流产、非瑞典语女性以及在非参与诊所预约的女性后,约69%的所有产前检查预约女性被招募。其中,2421名(83%)完成了两份问卷。约25%的女性遵循正常妊娠的标准就诊时间表,57%就诊次数更多,17%就诊次数更少。就诊次数与产次、医学诊断、抑郁症状、教育程度以及女性孕早期的偏好有关。女性自己认为就诊次数太少与孕早期希望就诊次数更多以及实际就诊次数低于标准时间表有关。认为就诊次数太多与既往不良分娩经历、希望就诊次数更少、有医学诊断、孩子多以及主要担忧有关。绝大多数女性(87.6%)总体上对产前检查满意,但对情感方面(76.9%)的满意度低于医学方面(82.3%)。未发现就诊次数与满意度之间存在关联,但女性自己认为就诊次数太少与对医疗及情感护理方面的不满有关,而认为就诊次数太多与对情感护理方面的不满有关。
三分之二的女性未遵循标准就诊时间表,大多数女性就诊次数更多。产前检查次数似乎相当符合女性的个体需求,并且在一定程度上符合她们自己的意愿。极少数女性对就诊次数以及总体产前检查不满意。