Shimoyama Yasuyuki, Kusano Motoyasu, Sugimoto Sayaka, Kawamura Osamu, Maeda Masaki, Minashi Keiko, Kuribayashi Shikou, Higuchi Tatsuya, Zai Hiroaki, Ino Kyoko, Horikoshi Tsutomu, Moki Fumitaka, Sugiyama Tadashi, Toki Munetoshi, Ohwada Tsuneo, Mori Masatomo
Department of Endoscopy and Endoscopic Surgery, Gunma University Hospital, Gunma, Japan.
J Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2005 Apr;20(4):643-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1440-1746.2005.03776.x.
An early and accurate evaluation by a general practitioner is needed to screen out non-gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) patients. A recent questionnaire (QUEST) highlighted problems with specificity and complexity, so the aim of the present study was to design a simplified questionnaire.
When admitted to hospital to undergo an upper gastrointestinal endoscopy for suspected GERD, 333 patients completed a 50-item questionnaire requiring 'yes/no' answers to different combinations of questions relating to symptoms of upper gastrointestinal tract conditions (e.g. GERD, ulcers and functional dyspepsia) and psychosomatic symptoms. The endoscopic diagnosis was then correlated with the rate of positive answers to each question.
Based on the analysis of the 50 items, the 8-10 questions most often answered affirmatively by each of the GERD and non-GERD groups were chosen for the simplified questionnaire. Three draft questionnaires were compiled. After calculating the sensitivity, specificity and accuracy in relation to the diagnosis of GERD and other conditions, it was found that questionnaire B (selection of persons answering 'yes' to at least one of questions 1-5 and exclusion of persons answering 'yes' to at least three of questions 7-10) had a high sensitivity, high specificity and low false positive rate.
A novel questionnaire was developed. It was designed to detect the symptoms of GERD while simultaneously excluding non-GERD patients. This simplified nine-item simplified questionnaire had a sensitivity of 79.8%, a specificity of 53.6% and an accuracy of 63.4%.
需要全科医生进行早期准确评估,以筛选出非胃食管反流病(GERD)患者。最近的一份问卷(QUEST)凸显了特异性和复杂性方面的问题,因此本研究的目的是设计一份简化问卷。
333例因疑似GERD入院接受上消化道内镜检查的患者,完成了一份包含50个项目的问卷,该问卷要求对与上消化道疾病(如GERD、溃疡和功能性消化不良)症状及心身症状相关的不同问题组合回答“是”或“否”。然后将内镜诊断结果与每个问题的肯定回答率进行关联分析。
基于对这50个项目的分析,为简化问卷选取了GERD组和非GERD组中每组最常得到肯定回答的8 - 10个问题。编制了三份问卷初稿。在计算与GERD及其他疾病诊断相关的敏感性、特异性和准确性后,发现问卷B(选择对问题1 - 5中至少一个回答“是”的人,并排除对问题7 - 10中至少三个回答“是”的人)具有高敏感性、高特异性和低假阳性率。
开发了一种新型问卷。其旨在检测GERD症状,同时排除非GERD患者。这份简化的九项问卷敏感性为79.8%,特异性为53.6%,准确性为63.4%。